44 replies to this topic

[loz]

Very hypothetical as I couldn't see him coming back to us as a) he would have his tail between his legs and he would probably know his position wouldn't be much better with us than it was before.

However just for arguments sake...

He is clearly not happy with the lack of first team football he is getting at Arsenal and we will need cover in that role when Essien and Mikel are away at the ACN.  

I would say a loan move would be ideal but I can't see Arsenal agreeing to that.

[The Moos]

Well since I never thought he played well in his position I wouldn't want him back. He was acceptable as RB but I don't think we need cover there at the moment.

[barak81]

In a heart beat, superb player and havng watched sidwell today we could do with a bit more quality.. iv daid before i think mikel would be better playing infrount of a deffesive mid and that for me should have been diarra in the wake of maka

[The Brit]

no...attitude problem...not welcome...two games out the team and he'd be moaning

[Alan]

I'd welcome him back with open arms. Good player with a lot of potential, and I was sad to see him go.

[canbeas]

he played in midfield against wigan because of injuries and was simply brilliant.

[The Brit]

talent isn't his problem...the question might as well be...Gallas...would you have him back? Would be interested to see how many takers for that idea there would be

[barak81]

"The Brit":2yi29tu3 said:

talent isn't his problem...the question might as well be...Gallas...would you have him back? Would be interested to see how many takers for that idea there would be

YES

[loz]

Taking Gallas back - now there is a question.  On ability there is no question whatsoever.  For me still the best centre half in Britain however the difference between Gallas and Diarra is that for Gallas to be taken back would mean displacing Carvalho and although that is something Jose should have done back when Gallas was a Chelsea player it is now something Carvalho doesn't deserve.

Diarra coming back would actually make sense because I believe Maka is in his last season and therefore Diarra could slot right in next season.

[Qaz]

Hasn't Mikel basically claimed that spot now?

His got alot of work to do to become what Makelele was for us, but he is definately a talent.

[Enrico]

I would. I was more excited by Diarra as a prospect than I was about Mikel.

I was going to say 'In a heartbeat' but bloody Bralk already used that.  {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_mad.gif

[The Brit]

mikel has maka's role nailed down

[loz]

"The Brit":2gzerdt6 said:

mikel has maka's role nailed down

Not if he can't curb those tackles.  At the moment he is potentially a 3-4 red cards a season player, especially when refs start making him a marked man.  Given how close titles are these days a player who can potentially cost you that many points every season is something that a lot of managers won't tolerate.  

He is still a kid so time to learn to sort that part of his game out but he better start making progress soon because at the moment it doesn't look like he is improving it one bit.  I would have had no complaints if he had walked yesterday.

[midlandblue]

I would take Diarra back for two reasons.

1. he's a bloody good player and will get better.
2. to piss of Arsenal.

[ethicalstrategy]

I'd take him back because then we wouldn't have to play Sidwell.

[Nibs]

I'd have Diarra and Gallas back - no question.

Would have been interesting to see us try out playing Gallas, Carvalho and JT (one of them playing sweeper perhaps?) with two attacking wing backs. Would be an even more useful option to have now with Maka's playing days coming to an end, as I am far from convinced that Mikel will ever be able to play that role well enough. As Loz says - nowhere near enough discipline.

[Elliott]

Would i take Diarra back? - In an instant.

It was madness to let him go there so cheaply.

[Chippy]

Diarra looked a good prospect but he is another one that believes he has a right to play, if getting left out of the team means disrupting things by moaning then I would say Arsenal are welcome to him,

that said a lot of it could have been made up and if he would just work hard and do his best when he got the chance I would gladly have him at Chelsea.

I will say though a choice out of Diarra goning or Mikel and I would have kept Mikel all day as I think one day he will be looked on as one of the best, just hope he's still with us when that happens.

Gallas again that whinging streak but what a player, I think I would take him back and force him to do a Bogarde rather than see him playing for Arsenal, it would certainly help our chances in the League {SMILIES_PATH}/icon_lol.gif

Rikky stood up and was counted though when Gallas went and I think is a lot closer on ability now than when he was holding willies CB spot.

[TomP]

Same goes for Diarra and Gallas.  I was gutted when they both left, but don't want them back.  

I think both of them are finding out that the grass is not always greener..

[Nibs]

"TomP":3egsb7pg said:

I think both of them are finding out that the grass is not always greener..

Diarra maybe but not Gallas. Looks like he's well happy now - he's playing well in his favoured position and is skipper.

Will never get over the fact that we let the best all round defender I have ever seen go to one of our biggest bloody rivals {SMILIES_PATH}/actions1.gif