I'd like to see him play defensive midfield with JT and Alex behind him. This would allow him to use his speed, passing and attacking prowess whilst not always needing to drop back and defend.... and that way we could sell Mikel too ;-)
Makalele was a quality player. Great close control and distribution. I still can't see what Mikel gives us. He takes too long to shift the ball from under his feet, doesn't get to it quick enough. Can't shoot (bar the one decent one he had against WHU the other day).