Alex Scott

@Sconnie Blue do you have a preference between Scott and Wharton?

Actually anyone who has watched both players care to share their thoughts on which player is better for us, and to be Caicedo partner?

 
I prefer Wharton but do like Scott.

Different players IMO, Wharton is the passer and tempo controller and Scott is the all action box to box midfielder.

Ironically I see a bit of Alonso in Wharton.

I feel that Palace have said to Chelsea no chance of Wharton this late in the window and Bournemouth have said publicy no but if there is a crazy bid we'll listen.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If I had to put money on it I would probably say that neither of these will happen and Alonso will go get Camavinga. Problem there of course is the injury record.

 
Both Wharton and Scott are very good. Wharton has the most eye catching moments because his forward passing is possibly the best in the league, but there are question marks about his off the ball game. From what I have seen, he's not really involved much off the ball.

Scott's close control of the ball and driving through midfield are his biggest strengths, but he offers a lot off the ball too. Caicedo doing the dirty work and moving the ball onto Scott to drive up the pitch and connect with our attackers could really benefit us. But at the same time, we have a similar profile of player in Lavia, he just can't stay fit.

I really do like Wharton, it's very hard to accept another team signing him with his passing ability, but I just don't see Palace selling him this season, and with Enzo likely leaving, we need a replacement. The fact that we keep bidding for Scott tells me they feel that Bournemouth are more open to selling than Palace.

 
If I had to put money on it I would probably say that neither of these will happen and Alonso will go get Camavinga. Problem there of course is the injury record.
I am pretty sure Camavinga was out of favour at Madrid while Alonso was there. Although some of that may have been injury related.

 
I am pretty sure Camavinga was out of favour at Madrid while Alonso was there. Although some of that may have been injury related.
You're right on both counts I think. Certainly Tchouameni held the position. Then there was the punch up. I have just seen a few puff pieces centred around Scott and Wharton and Camavinga always seems to be third choice on the lists.

 
From your descriptions Scott seems to have a similar game to Caicedo then. Would they be a like for like partnership?

 
From your descriptions Scott seems to have a similar game to Caicedo then. Would they be a like for like partnership?
Caicedo is better at the defensive side of the game. Scott is better at progressing with the ball. Think of it being a bit like Kante and Kovacic.

 
Caicedo is better at the defensive side of the game. Scott is better at progressing with the ball. Think of it being a bit like Kante and Kovacic.
That was a very, very good tandem. Thank you Scott.

 
Caicedo is better at the defensive side of the game. Scott is better at progressing with the ball. Think of it being a bit like Kante and Kovacic.
I was going to say he reminds me a bit of Kovacic. Probably a better tackler with more pace.

 
I don't get the obsession with Scott because to me Wharton is the better player

 
That makes both the Palace and Bournemouth coaches to have catagorically stated their player will not be sold this window.

Scott and Wharton off the table, and there is 0 chance Arsenal sell us Zubimendi.

That combined with still no city offer adds more weight to Enzo likely to stay.

 
That makes both the Palace and Bournemouth coaches to have catagorically stated their player will not be sold this window.

Scott and Wharton off the table, and there is 0 chance Arsenal sell us Zubimendi.

That combined with still no city offer adds more weight to Enzo likely to stay.
Said this from the beginning.

 
Said this from the beginning.
A few are also saying cities offer, should it come, will be far less than the 120mill minimum fee we set 2 weeks ago.

If true that would be just another effort to destabilize us.

 
A few are also saying cities offer, should it come, will be far less than the 120mill minimum fee we set 2 weeks ago.

If true that would be just another effort to destabilize us.
We aren’t the ones desperately in need of a midfielder. Starting the season with only Anderson and a teenager is not going to end well. I say screw them to there self inflicted disaster.

 
Back
Top