Alex Scott

After seeing what we are lacking in midfield I`m not sure Scott is the right fit, we need a solid midfielder willing to sit and battle, bring strength and structure and that would go against his natural game which is to carry the ball forward at every opportunity.
I actually think we need 2 new midfielders.

An Alex Scott type and the type you described above.

 
We need a Matic for our Kante.
I'm saying this for months here. Zubimendi or Scott would not work IMHO because we are not controlling football matches that much, nor we will anytime soon. Under Alonso we will need to defend the transition a lot and, if fit, James is as good as any other midfielder in this world next to Caicedo.

It's a big IF, but once Caicedo is back and James stays fit, people will be amazed at how good they are together. James will grow into that role as long as his muscles allow it. He has all the tools to play that role.

 
I'm saying this for months here. Zubimendi or Scott would not work IMHO because we are not controlling football matches that much, nor we will anytime soon. Under Alonso we will need to defend the transition a lot and, if fit, James is as good as any other midfielder in this world next to Caicedo.

It's a big IF, but once Caicedo is back and James stays fit, people will be amazed at how good they are together. James will grow into that role as long as his muscles allow it. He has all the tools to play that role.
Scott is another all action midfielder. We need control in midfield, isn't this why Alonso wanted Xhaka? James isn't the answer for me because I think he lacks the off ball understanding of playing that role.

 
Scott is another all action midfielder. We need control in midfield, isn't this why Alonso wanted Xhaka? James isn't the answer for me because I think he lacks the off ball understanding of playing that role.
Alonso's Chelsea is a bit different than his Leverkusen one because of a small little thing. On paper was still a 3-4-3 with two classic midfielders and two wing-backs, but when Hoffman was playing, he was also dropping in midfield. When Hlozek was playing instead of Hoffman, Wirtz was deployed centrally and Hlozek was joining Boniface in attack. So most of the times Alonso was having three in midfield.

Here, as we can see so far, Palmer and Rogers stay in the pockets most of the time, with maybe Joao Pedro dropping centrally for a little bit to link-up the play. So it's basically two in midfield all the time to do the hard work and the reason I think the best partner for Caicedo would be someone similar to him, but just a little bit more polished technically. James would be perfect. If fit.

 
Zubimendi or Scott would not work IMHO because we are not controlling football matches that much, nor we will anytime soon.
I agree based on the last few games, but Zubimendi is a very different sort of player to Alex Scott. Zubimendi is a world-class controlling midfielder, he allows Rice to get forward but also has the technical ability to carry the ball, beat the press and switch play with accurate passes and through calls.

 
Bournemouth now has put him up for sale after the injury.

c**ts wasted so much time saying not for sale only to be asking for 100M now that he's injured
 
60M in the Summer was a good market opportunity.
100M is just having your pants pulled down, just wait til Sp*rs are relegated and resign Gallagher for peanuts in the Summer if this is the profile we’re going for.
 
60M in the Summer was a good market opportunity.
100M is just having your pants pulled down, just wait til Sp*rs are relegated and resign Gallagher for peanuts in the Summer if this is the profile we’re going for.
Except Scott is a class above Gallagher. As much as I love Conor, he's a wholehearted terrier and nothing much more. His deficiencies are on show at Spurs.
 
Except Scott is a class above Gallagher. As much as I love Conor, he's a wholehearted terrier and nothing much more. His deficiencies are on show at Spurs.
No he isn't. Alex Scott is just a Kovacic regen. Can carry a ball but can't pass or shoot, which is pretty important in football.
Gallagher scored as much for us in 23/24 than Alex Scott has managed in his entire PL career.
 
No he isn't. Alex Scott is just a Kovacic regen. Can carry a ball but can't pass or shoot, which is pretty important in football.
Gallagher scored as much for us in 23/24 than Alex Scott has managed in his entire PL career.
You're rarely if ever wrong apart from this.
 
No he isn't. Alex Scott is just a Kovacic regen. Can carry a ball but can't pass or shoot, which is pretty important in football.
Gallagher scored as much for us in 23/24 than Alex Scott has managed in his entire PL career.
I'd take a Kovacic regen right now. Good player who had a good career. How many Champions League's did he win? He wasn't always a starter but sometimes he was and it's no coincidence that he always found himself playing a part at teams that challenge for the CL.
Weird comparison to try to downplay Alex Scott and big up Gallagher who couldn't cut it at Chelsea then Atletico and now plays for an atrocious Spurs side...

Anyways, I think Alex Scott is a talented player, but if he becomes available, I'd love us to try and get Elliot Anderson! Cracking midfielder, who can do it all. Him and Caicedo in the middle of the park would be scary stuff.
 
We need midfielders - just unsure about Scott. Midfielder fees are inflated. The recent benchmark to be in Anderson, and I don’t see Scott near his level for a comparable 9 figure fee.
 
January could be a strange transfer window, without knowing what’s happening with city it’s hard to know what the mkt will look like….. is there going to be an exodus of players, will they be cheap??
£125m for Enzo anyone??? Haha good luck!
 
I'd take a Kovacic regen right now. Good player who had a good career. How many Champions League's did he win? He wasn't always a starter but sometimes he was and it's no coincidence that he always found himself playing a part at teams that challenge for the CL.
Weird comparison to try to downplay Alex Scott and big up Gallagher who couldn't cut it at Chelsea then Atletico and now plays for an atrocious Spurs side...

Anyways, I think Alex Scott is a talented player, but if he becomes available, I'd love us to try and get Elliot Anderson! Cracking midfielder, who can do it all. Him and Caicedo in the middle of the park would be scary stuff.
Just because he’s played for big clubs doesn’t mean it’s what we need. All those big clubs sold Kovacic because of what he lacked. Nacho has 6 UCL’s to his name but I wouldn’t want us to sign him at CB either.

I will never allow Alex Scott propaganda to work its way into this forum.
 
I'd take a Kovacic regen right now. Good player who had a good career. How many Champions League's did he win? He wasn't always a starter but sometimes he was and it's no coincidence that he always found himself playing a part at teams that challenge for the CL.
Weird comparison to try to downplay Alex Scott and big up Gallagher who couldn't cut it at Chelsea then Atletico and now plays for an atrocious Spurs side...

Anyways, I think Alex Scott is a talented player, but if he becomes available, I'd love us to try and get Elliot Anderson! Cracking midfielder, who can do it all. Him and Caicedo in the middle of the park would be scary stuff.
We're in the position we are in because we sold Gallagher, replaced him with filthy Enzo, signed Lavia who is scared of minutes on the pitch, and other midfielders who couldnt do the job asked of them.

so thats, Lavia (58 million) Chuckwemka (20Million), Ugochukwu (23 million), casadei (12million), Enzo (120 million) - that's nearly 250 million spent, in bigger words quarter of a billion pounds spent on players no longer at the club, none of them good enough to start, Gallagher's sale underpinned the colleciotn of sh*t who replaced him and was pure profit to the vulture capitalist runing and asset stripping the club.

Sorry, I dont get the idea he wasnt good enough, he is, he is a brilliant player doing exactly the sort of thing we need a player to do in midfield, run, be physical, score the odd goal and set the team up.. We signed Henderson to do this job, looked at Xaka. In that terrible spurs side, he actually looks decent this season and is forcing his way into that midifeld.

As for Scott, talented player, yes would be a good purchase, but not at 100 million...

Anderson, choose city in the summer/last year. I cant see City being forced to sell.
 
Just because he’s played for big clubs doesn’t mean it’s what we need. All those big clubs sold Kovacic because of what he lacked. Nacho has 6 UCL’s to his name but I wouldn’t want us to sign him at CB either.

I will never allow Alex Scott propaganda to work its way into this forum.
Actually a prime Nacho would be an upgrade on our CB's. Also this works both ways... There's a reason whenever Kovacic was sold, he ended up at a top club. From 2015 onwards up until now he has always played for one of Real, Chelsea and Man City. That's not exactly a bad resume.

Contrast that with Gallagher who was sold by Chelsea after 2 seasons, then binned by Atletico after 1,5 seasons and now plays for a rubbish Spurs side (not even a regular there).

I get that you subjectively don't rate Kovacic and Scott, but if you're trying to build a case for Gallagher over Scott, using Kovacic as a reference point for why Gallagher is superior, is just a bad choice that doesn't hold up. I don't even have to argue my opinion on the players, bring up stats or anything and my case is already built on a way stronger foundation by just bringing up indisputable facts.
 
Back
Top