What's new

Ben Arfa?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Is he good enough to go into the starting lineup straight away? If he's not good enough, then he can stay where he is. We've got promising youngsters of our own who can be our back up players. He has looked promising, but I haven't seen him play this season so I can't say if he's really good enough.

 
Why not? Sounds decent and a youngster. But where will he fit? Scolari won't drop Anelka or Drogba, Joe Cole? But still don't thinkhe would fit.

 
hes got a sweet left foot and it ain't asif weve got an abundance of talent on the left wing aye?? :huh:

 
After being told that no fund would be available unless Scolari sells, I am pleasantly surprised that we are linked to Marseille's Ben Arfa. The French international is not very tall, but has vital skills to improve our wing play.

In 19 starts & 4 substitution appearance for Marseille, Ben has netted 7 with 5 assist. That is a good work rate. The Lyon transfer was undisclosed but 10 mil quid is a decent price to pay.

Hopefully, we get this deal wrap up. It may be better if we can do a swap deal that include Florent Malouda.

 
21? Far too young and he's nowhere near being a has-been so why should we sign him?

By the way Octville didn't you notice this thread before you posted yours in the General forum?

 
Johan Gruyff said:
But where will he fit? Scolari won't drop Anelka or Drogba, Joe Cole?
Click to expand...
Ben Arfa plays on the left, doesn't he? So we wouldn't have to drop any of those players to make room for him. The question you gotta ask is would Scolari drop Malouda and Kalou to make room for Ben Arfa?

 
If he's anything like the French winger we already have then he can stay away from the Bridge

 
If he's that good, young and French why haven't Arsenal got him?

 
I would prefer to see Ashley Young or Agbonlahor because we know more about them. They won't sell but Malouda & Deco for Young & Agbonlahor? Malouda & Deco have been very poor. But Deco has only been there for 6 months and looks like LFS's favourite.

 
Be surprised if this one comes off at 10 million , he only signed for Marseille in July for 9.5, unles they're skint too. A part exchange for Malouda would be good :D

 
Sounds like a good option to me, the only thing is we do need to offload someone so he wont spend the rest of his chelsea career on the bench. I cant see us getting Ashley Young, Man City will outbid us if he is on the market. If we had any foresight, we should have signed him 2 years ago when he went to Villa .

 
icecoolguy22 said:
I cant see us getting Ashley Young, Man City will outbid us if he is on the market. If we had any foresight, we should have signed him 2 years ago when he went to Villa .
Click to expand...
If we had bought him two years ago, he wouldn't have made the progress he has during the past few years as he would have been rotting in our reserves with no hope of playing in the first team. Sorry to be so negative, but that's how I see it.

 
Maksimov said:
If we had bought him two years ago, he wouldn't have made the progress he has during the past few years as he would have been rotting in our reserves with no hope of playing in the first team. Sorry to be so negative, but that's how I see it.
Click to expand...
Thats kind of my point, we only bid for the establised star, rather than give the likes of young Ronaldo, Farbragas a go. God knows maybe Sinclair is as good as Ashley Young, if only we play him couple of times a month. To me, Ashley Young is just the flavour of the month, or year, just like SWP. If we are going to pay a record fee for him, lets do it after 2 years after he prove he is the real deal.

 
Where did Ashley Young come from anyway? He just appeared out of nowhere and 2 years down the line he's an MVP.

But I still think Ben Arfa's a good gamble. He's young and already got a big name, so if he's crap, we sell him on for double what we got for him in the first place!

 
Ruh Buh Juh said:
Where did Ashley Young come from anyway? He just appeared out of nowhere and 2 years down the line he's an MVP.But I still think Ben Arfa's a good gamble. He's young and already got a big name, so if he's crap, we sell him on for double what we got for him in the first place!
Click to expand...
You would think he's a good gamble, after all, you can't go back after you started a topic that people are spending their valuable time on, and end up saying he's crap! Sorry, Ruh Buh Juh, but it had to be said! Just making a point. You maybe trying to stick to your guns but, you never know....

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know l'OM bought Ben Arfa to make up for the loss of Nasri, so I really cant see them letting go of him this early or that cheap.

But that said, I know he has been a problem child in the past and doesnt have the greatest attitude. Maybe a manager like Scolari, who has settled down the likes of Quaresma and Ronaldo, is something he needs.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top