As a manager I am a huge admirer of Rafa Benitez. Although he may have failed to grasp exactly what is needed to succeed in the English Premiership, when it comes to the Champions League, there really isn’t a better tactician out there in the whole of Europe. However on a human level, and I’m talking purely with regards to footballing matters, I am rapidly losing all respect I have for the man.
Following last night’s unfortunate 1-1 draw with Chelsea in the first leg of their Champions League semi-final, a game Liverpool clearly deserved to win, Benitez hit out at referee Konrad Plautz.
"One minute [of stoppage time] in the first half, four minutes in the second half - and two hundred fouls!,” blasted the ex-Valencia boss.
"Yes [i’m not happy with the referee]. I'm really disappointed. It is not the first time.”
So when were these other times then Rafa?
Maybe it was in the first leg of the last 16 against Inter at Anfield when Marco Materazzi was sent off after just half-an-hour for two offences that were never befitting of a yellow card. After the game Benitez astonishingly had the nerve to claim, stone-faced, that the Matrix deserved to go.
Possibly it could have been in the second leg of this tie at San Siro when Nicolas Burdisso received a second yellow after 50 minutes following a routine coming-together with Lucas Leiva. This decision was so appalling that British pundit Andy Gray, on Sky Sports, described it as “shocking”. Though yet again Benitez failed to acknowledge, at the end of the tie, that these two red cards had played any role whatsoever in Liverpool’s victory.
Fast-forward to the quarter-final against Arsenal, and we had exactly the same scenario as the Inter tie, only this time it was a tale not of two red cards, but of two penalties.
In the first game at the Emirates, Arsenal outplayed Liverpool for long spells, but could only manage a 1-1 draw after Alexander Hleb was denied a stonewall penalty by the Dutch referee. In the return match at Anfield a week later the Gunners had again created numerous opportunities, particularly in the first half hour, and were set to go through on away goals with the scores at 2-2. Then with five minutes remaining Kolo Toure was harshly adjudged to have pulled back Ryan Babel in the area, the referee pointed to the spot, and Steven Gerrard did the rest.
After the game, was their any acknowledgement from Benitez that his side had enjoyed a huge slice of lady luck in both legs of the tie?
Of course not!
This just makes Benitez’ criticism of the officiating last night all the harder to digest. It smacks of the most two-faced, hypocritical pretence ever imaginable.
Yes, on the balance of play, Liverpool deserved to win the game, and they were also hugely unlucky to concede an own goal in the last minute of injury time. However given what happened in the ties with Inter and Arsenal, Benitez has no right to complain.
Indeed if we are to talk about the referee last night it is probably Chelsea who may feel hard done by for not receiving a penalty following a possible foul in the area, at 0-0, by Jamie Carragher on Didier Drogba.
Of course Benitez didn’t see that incident either.
What are your views on this topic? Is Benitez a hypocrite? Does he have any right to complain given what happened in Liverpool’s knockout ties with Inter and Arsenal in the last rounds. Do you think he should be more honest. Goal.com wants to know what YOU think…