Celery1989
First Team Regular
- Messages
- 2,004
- Reaction score
- 171
So following your logic Stewart Downing should still be in the England squad despite his awful season? I realise that all our managers have played him a lot but then what choice have they had? Essien has spent about half of the duration of Mikel's tenure in the treatment room!And yet every manager we've had had selected him for the big games. Yes, even the Blessed Mourinho, Double-winning (and cruelly sacked) Ancelotti and Mighty Guus. These are all top, top managers, probably some of the best in the world, and they all think he makes a contribution to any side they put out.
We are all fans, who pay our money, but I think that we have already established that none of us are now, nor have ever been, in the top levels of football in any capacity, other than sitting in our pants playing Football Manager or the other one.
I have my reservations about Mikel, but I am content that managers who have won everything there is to win in club football know a little bit more than me.
Kev
ps - Just - the same applies to Kalou, in my opinion.
Sorry but Mikel simply hasn't been anywhere near as good as advertised over the 5 years he's been with us. Need I remind you that we paid £16 Million for him which is a ludicrous amount of money to pay for any 18 year old who's only ever played in the Norwegian league. He was dubbed as the heir apparent to Makelele who, quite frankly, was in another universe compared to JOM. We were lucky to have the best holding midfielder of this century in our side and therefore comparison seems unfair. But the fact of the matter is that there are better holding players out there who offer more than Mikel's limited repertoire of skills.
Yes, he was excellent under RDM, and hopefully that continues. If it does, great and we're all happy. Hopefully this could be the season that Mikel emerges and can become of greater use going forward. If he could add a killer through ball to his game and greater consistency then I'd be sold on the guy. Until that's the case, he deserves to be scrutinised, IMO.

