This is a nonsensical argument, i'm literally scratching my head at it. Sanchez is a winger, who can back up as striker, so yes i'd sign him as a winger, because he is a world class winger, not as a midfielder/ wingback/ CAM/ striker. Essien was a box to box midfielder, that was his position, and he was the best in the world for several years. So yes, i'd sign him as a box-to box midfielder, not a CAM, CB, and left back. Azpilicueta is a better player in all of his positions than Cahill, so obviously i'd prefer him in my team.
I'm not getting into the 'ive watched more games than you' thing, as i'm not 8 years old. Versatile players are useful, i never debated that, in that rare occasion that someone gets sent off then great, they can swap positions. But there is no point signing a player who is just 'good' all over that park as opposed to someone who is great in one position. A player can only play in one position at one time, i'd rather they actually have a specified role rather than being seen as someone who fills in a vacant spot.