Random Rumours

Isn't that exactly what's happened?

I think you're overestimating the club's control here. Just because we're batting our eyelashes it doesn't make it any easier to sign backups, especially when said players and clubs are well aware they are backup options.
My point is that it's a question of timing. If we bid enough money and leave the selling club enough time to find a suitable replacement, then at least we have a chance that they'll seriously consider it. Desperate attempts to snatch a key defender from any club in the last few days of the transfer window are almost guaranteed to end in failure.

 
True, but in my opinion it's equally likely (without information to suggest otherwise) that this is the fastest the club were possibly able to move. People are just assuming that the club have sat on their hands based on little information and the board are just a convenient scapegoat.

The pool of players who are both A) competent and B) willing to come to us is small because of our circumstances this season. I'm not sure if people are fully appreciative of this reality.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If there's one thing I can be critical of, perhaps it was the club underestimated this reality themselves. We really should have been rivalling Barca and Liverpool for the likes of Samuel Umtiti and Joel Matip who are very promising/solid backup defenders respectively, however the club appears to have aimed higher and missed.

 
True, but in my opinion it's equally likely (without information to suggest otherwise) that this is the fastest the club were possibly able to move. People are just assuming that the club have sat on their hands based on little information and the board are just a convenient scapegoat.

The pool of players who are both A) competent and B) willing to come to us is small because of our circumstances this season. I'm not sure if people are fully appreciative of this reality.
I see your point there Sydney and it's a valid one. Only we had the same problem last summer and our circumstances were very different, us being the champions of England and still in the CL.

 
Take this with a massive chunk of salt, but my colleague is a Spaniard from Madrid and his familiy is friends with Florentino.

James will stay
Isco will be loaned but possibly to Malaga, not Tottenham
They have a signing they will announce today, a Uruguayan Striker, so unless we have a Figo 2.0 on the card that would be Cavani?

I'll go back to never speculating if none of that happens, but that's what he said.

 

 
True, but in my opinion it's equally likely (without information to suggest otherwise) that this is the fastest the club were possibly able to move. People are just assuming that the club have sat on their hands based on little information and the board are just a convenient scapegoat.

The pool of players who are both A) competent and B) willing to come to us is small because of our circumstances this season. I'm not sure if people are fully appreciative of this reality.
Why do you think it's small?  It won't be small if the board was willing to stump up the cash for it.  The fact that the club has had to resort to last minute desperate moves show that it isn't as small as you think.

 
Take this with a massive chunk of salt, but my colleague is a Spaniard from Madrid and his familiy is friends with Florentino.

James will stay
Isco will be loaned but possibly to Malaga, not Tottenham
They have a signing they will announce today, a Uruguayan Striker, so unless we have a Figo 2.0 on the card that would be Cavani?

I'll go back to never speculating if none of that happens, but that's what he said.

 
Cant see madrid signing cavani, when they have morata, and benzema. Maybe it will be one for the future.

The rest looks pretty likely though, however i would a deadline deal for james.

 
BBC reckon James McCarthy is available from Everton, which is interesting. He's a player I've always rated, and is someone I think would fit into Conte's plans quite well. He's also only 25 (and hugely experienced considering his age), and has the added bonus of being home-grown. Any takers?

 
BBC reckon James McCarthy is available from Everton, which is interesting. He's a player I've always rated, and is someone I think would fit into Conte's plans quite well. He's also only 25 (and hugely experienced considering his age), and has the added bonus of being home-grown. Any takers?
I'd be happy if we signed him for the same reason I mentioned in the Sissoko thread. He's no Naingollan but physical and knows when to put his foot in. Alongside Kante/Matic we'd have a midfield capable of competing for top 4 IMO.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'd be happy if we signed him for the same reason I mentioned in the Sissoko thread. He's no Naingollan but physical and knows when to put his foot in. Alongside Kante/Matic we'd have a midfield capable of competing for top 4 IMO.
I think we need someone who can chip in with goals and assists in midfield, James McCarthy does neither of those things and i don't think he is any better than Oscar. Matic and Kante are more than enough for the defensive side of the game, what we need is creativity in there, it's why i want Fabregas to play in front of Oscar.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think we need someone who can chip in with goals and assists in midfield, James McCarthy does neither of those things. Matic and Kante are more than enough for the defensive side of the game, what we need is creativity in there, it's why i want Fabregas to play in front of Oscar.
Yeah I do agree, we do need goals from midfield and I'm certainly not saying the likes of McCarthy/Sissoko/Brozovic should start ahead of Fabregas/Oscar against mid/lower table opposition. It's just for me against top opposition goals from midfield becomes less of a factor, as Mourinho's record here would suggest in the big games we should be looking to park the bus/nullify our opponent, we can't do that with Cesc (as he said himself on Sky Sports last season he's a defensive liability).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jason Cundy has apparently been told by Bruce Buck that we'll be getting two players in, presumably that means Alonso plus someone else.

 
I think McCarthy would be a more natural fit than Matic as the 'second man' in a three-man midfield of Kanté, someone, and Fabregas/Oscar. He's physically good, has a fantastic work rate, and is a tidy enough passer.

He definitely fits the profile of the kind of player Conte wants in his midfield, but I think you are right that a) he wouldn't necessarily start, and b) he doesn't really give us anything we don't already have.

 
So, that leaves the missing piece to this wonderful window. 

40 odd million. 

Fernando Torres.

Do the deal, board.

Don't disappoint us.

Then we can really start to celebrate. :|

 
hahaha....Don't you get bored of whinging about whinging?

When there's plenty to grumble about, grumble away. I say. :]

 
I think McCarthy would be a more natural fit than Matic as the 'second man' in a three-man midfield of Kanté, someone, and Fabregas/Oscar. He's physically good, has a fantastic work rate, and is a tidy enough passer.

He definitely fits the profile of the kind of player Conte wants in his midfield, but I think you are right that a) he wouldn't necessarily start, and b) he doesn't really give us anything we don't already have.




 
My points exactly.   ::clap2::

 
Back
Top