Renato sanches

That is fair enough of course but to my eyes he did not.

The appeal to authority is always tempting, especially when that authority supports the case you are making but such appeals are not automatically decisive in settling debates. Authority once held that the sun goes around the Earth which, to the naked eye, it does of course.

Bayern are a fantastic organisation, who almost always get things right. Almost is only almost however.

I don't want to fall out with anybody over this. Others, many others, think I'm wrong but Sanches did not impress me at the Euros.
Why are you insisting on following this tangent, he impressed everyone enough to win young player of the tournament, and impressed one of the best clubs in Europe enough to buy him, so all you're saying is you have a wildly opposing view to football exerts, how is that to your credit? That he can impress pundits, sports writers and Bayern scouts but not you..ok, and if they got it all wrong and you got it right, you should certainly be a football scout at the top level. 

 
Why are you insisting on following this tangent, he impressed everyone enough to win young player of the tournament, and impressed one of the best clubs in Europe enough to buy him, so all you're saying is you have a wildly opposing view to football exerts, how is that to your credit? That he can impress pundits, sports writers and Bayern scouts but not you..ok, and if they got it all wrong and you got it right, you should certainly be a football scout at the top level. 
Becoming a scout is a not only a question of aptitude, it is also about opportunity. People's lives go in different directions. People including you I assume.

Sanches signed for Bayern before Euro 2016 so whatever impressed them to make their decision, it can't have been his performances there.

We have all seen panel voted award decisions with which we disagree. For example, the election of Lionel Messi as player of the tournament at Brazil '14 was widely ridiculed. Are you suggesting that we fans should simply defer to the opinions of 'experts'? I haven't checked your posts, but I'm willing to bet that this is not what you do.

In any case, Young Player of The Tournament is a 'relative' award. It may mean nothing more than that all other age qualified players were even worse. In fact what I think happened is that Sanches came into the tournament with a reputation, a big move in his pocket, scored a nice looking goal, and picked up some lazy votes.

I'm expressing my view in a place where football fans come to do just that. I hope you'll agree that I'm entitled to support my view when it's challenged, especially when that is done in a way which is clearly intended to belittle it. I hope too, you'll agree that this is not something I've attempted to do to you, or anyone else who has a different opinion to mine.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well then Player of the Tournament could also be perceived as relative, surely? Along with Player of the Season, the Ballon D'or, the Academy Awards, the Nobel Prize, the Euro 2016 Cup itself? Portugal were the least sh*t team, so they won. Every award is relative, it seems pointless to discredit it for that. They should change the award to 'Least-sh*t Young Player of the Tournament' and 'Least poo player of the season'

 
Just a statement of the truth. :)
So every "player of the year/tournamet/trophy/league" award is relative, and only given out because all other qualified players were worse. Why is this one different?

 
So every "player of the year/tournamet/trophy/league" award is relative, and only given out because all other qualified players were worse. Why is this one different?
That is more than I said. It is a relative award in that it only means 'better' than the rest. That could mean they were all great and the winner was outstanding, it could mean all candidates were crap and the winner was less bad than the rest, or something in between.

That's a simple statement of the truth. To have been chosen the winner of an award among a reasonably small group does not necessarily make a statement about your finite quality. It only means better than the rest. At least it means that if the award was well chosen. If it wasn't well chosen, as sometimes happens, then it doesn't even mean that.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
That is more than I said. It is a relative award in that it only means 'better' than the rest. That could mean they were all great and the winner was outstanding, it could mean all candidates were crap and the winner was less bad than the rest, or something in between.

That's a simple statement of the truth. To have been chosen the winner of an award among a reasonably small group does not necessarily make a statement about your finite quality. It only means better than the rest. At least it means that if the award was well chosen. If it wasn't well chosen, as sometimes happens, then it doesn't even mean that.
So he was better than all young players in Europe, not bad that. I think that's what best means, better than everyone else, no need to redefine it. To get in to a first team, you're better than all young players in your country that didn't, to win the competition, you're in a team better than all the other teams that have young players,, then to be selected as the best of the tournament, means he was the best of the most elite young players in Europe, that's not a small group, that's the end of a long vetting process that saw him excel tens of thousands of young professional football players. It's not like there were loads of better young players that decided not to bother to play in the tournament because they were doing more important things.  

By saying he isn't good just better than the rest is saying every young player in Europe is crap because has excelled them all at that point by virtue of his achievement yet he is not good..in your opinion of course. What a way to start in a new forum, you're not discussing your point anymore you're just being pedantic at this point, juggling terms, looking for loops, trying to redefine established logic to suit your naritive again at the detriment in knowledge of all the football experts who voted for him and the scouts at one of Europes best clubs who saw that same talent and bought him.

Is he the best young player in Europe, maybe not, certainly not, but he excelled them all at that tournament, so to say he had bad tournament is just stupid and to carry it on this much trying to outsmart everyone is almost patronising

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I still think if we wanted we could lease Sanches. I.e. buy him but give Bayern a buyback option. Alternatively take him on loan.

Reading between the lines of Bayerns statements that seems to be the message. We still need more depth in central midfield.

 
Can't we loan the guy?
Defeats the purpose of a loan though he will go from their bench to ours if we want a back up it's easier to keep matic I'd love to buy sanchez because he can be developed to a top player but a loan for what...

 
I have read a few articles claiming Bayern are looking for around £40 million
Kind of steep for him. He only seemed to be so good at the Euros, apart from that I've not heard much about him. Is he one of these players who had an amazing international tournament, like Rodriguez?

 
I would rather go for goretzka. Sanches is very similar to kante and bakayoko, goretzka would be a nice option. 

Bayern are looking to replace sanches with goretzka themselves, maybe if acted fast we could jump the queue. He would be relatively cheap with only a year left on his contract. 

 
Defeats the purpose of a loan though he will go from their bench to ours if we want a back up it's easier to keep matic I'd love to buy sanchez because he can be developed to a top player but a loan for what...
I think we can pull off a loan with the option to buy. If he can't hack it here then we can send him back to Bayern. 

 
I think we can pull off a loan with the option to buy. If he can't hack it here then we can send him back to Bayern. 
 Oils do buy if he develops well enough for us to want to buy him Bayern will probably say cheers and want him back, good CM's are in short supply 

 
Apparently 43M secures his services.

If 30M is being floated for Barkley this seems a no brainer to me.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top