We should never have got rid of Schurrle. He was the ideal winger for us. It's just a shame that Jose didn't rate him massively and had issues with his defensive work.
I absolutely love Schurrle, but he was far from ideal for us. He is a limited player who excels at movement off the ball / making diagonal runs in behind a defence, qualities that are nullified against the packed defences we usually come up against. He wasn't good at the things you traditionally expect from a winger i.e. dribbling in tight spaces, going past a player, crossing etc. He tried his hardest at defending but he was awful at it. If he wasn't getting in behind and scoring, he offered nothing - pretty much the exact opposite of Willian, who offers everything but end product.
I do think Jose had high hopes for him post-World Cup, which is probably why we didn't even consider the likes of Sanchez. I think he started the first couple of games of the season and did alright, but I remember him being atrocious in the game against Swansea where we massively struggled in the 1st half. He was subbed at half-time, and we completely dominated the second half, and then the mystery illness took over and he didn't do enough to justify his selection thereafter.
Maybe we could have tried using him as a second striker, the way Atletico use Griezmann, but he wasn't good enough technically to consistently start on the wings for us - certainly not the right-wing. Think he's destined to be a great super-sub type player, but unfortunately, he didn't want to accept that role with us.
I'll still always root for him because he seemed like a very likeable guy with a great attitude and a genuine affection for our club, but being better than Salah and Cuadrado does not make him the answer to our RW woes.