Like you will easily pick Costa who can only play better as a center forward over a Sanchez who can play incredibly well anywhere in a front 3? Or you will easily pick Matic over a versatile Essien? Or you will pick Cahill over a versatile Azpilicueta?I'd prefer a master at one position than a jack of all trades to be honest. Can is mediocre at best. We have plenty of all rounders in the squad, we need specialists like Cesc and Kante.
I get what you are saying, but Matic, GC, Costa are no where near "masters".Like you will easily pick Costa who can only play better as a center forward over a Sanchez who can play incredibly well anywhere in a front 3? Or you will easily pick Matic over a versatile Essien? Or you will pick Cahill over a versatile Azpilicueta?
Seems you have never watched match whereby all substitutions have been made and then a player gets sent off. Lol, Barcelona VS Chelsea springs into my mind. I wonder what the outcome of that game would have been if Ramires wasn't versatile to play as a Right Back for us!
This is a nonsensical argument, i'm literally scratching my head at it. Sanchez is a winger, who can back up as striker, so yes i'd sign him as a winger, because he is a world class winger, not as a midfielder/ wingback/ CAM/ striker. Essien was a box to box midfielder, that was his position, and he was the best in the world for several years. So yes, i'd sign him as a box-to box midfielder, not a CAM, CB, and left back. Azpilicueta is a better player in all of his positions than Cahill, so obviously i'd prefer him in my team.Like you will easily pick Costa who can only play better as a center forward over a Sanchez who can play incredibly well anywhere in a front 3? Or you will easily pick Matic over a versatile Essien? Or you will pick Cahill over a versatile Azpilicueta?
Seems you have never watched match whereby all substitutions have been made and then a player gets sent off. Lol, Barcelona VS Chelsea springs into my mind. I wonder what the outcome of that game would have been if Ramires wasn't versatile to play as a Right Back for us!
He isn't, he's mediocre at best. Scores a few screamers here and there and everyone forgets how average the rest of his game isIs Can really that good to warrant these praises? I'm sorry but I can't see it
I don't agree. I've made assessments in fewer games. Assessments which have proved to be accurate. In the cases of Carlton Cole, Jody Morris, Kakuta, Bamford, Sinclair, Feruz and others you won't have heard of unless you follow the youth team as closely as I do, I've made correct assessments in less than 20 minutes of watching them play live*. What's more, they were all 18 or younger at the time.Well he only played 4 league games and he is only 19, so to draw a conclusion I think would be very short sighted...
Proves nothing. In any case it depends on your definition of 'full'. He did not start all of the games, and did not finish all of those he did start. In the final, he really ought to have been subbed before he was....as for what supports him having world class potential I think is clear, he won a European title as a full first 11 player at 18 years old...
You are right, we have discussed this before so you'll remember what I think of that award. I challenge people to view the all touches videos and then tell me they saw performances of high merit. It's opinion of course, but I think they'll struggle to make that claim honestly. Indeed I posted one such vid during that discussion and the first response came from someone who, I think, takes your view of Sanches. His comment was, wow, that video makes him look terrible. I'm not certain I remember the wording 100% accurately, but that was definitely the gist of it....and won young player of the tournament...
Yes, you are right about this but Sanches comes under discussion in the Rumours section because of stories that Bayern are willing to part with him. I do not know that the story is true of course but, if it is, which would say more about the player; the fact that Bayern bought him in the first place, or that; having watched him up close for a season, they are ready to give up on him?...to add to that he was bought by one of the biggest clubs on the planet at a very young age with the mind of playing first team football, so I that would suggest without doubt they felt he had world class potential...
No, you are right once more, you can't loose it like that. Before you can loose something however, you have to have had it in the first place. I say again I've seen no evidence of world class potential in this lad's actual performances. I'd go further and guess that, if people were watching him without knowledge of the hype created by the move to Bayern, fewer of them would now believe that they saw it either.can you lose all that in one season?
In a perfect world,i think our formation requires 2 CMs who are equally very good at attacking and defending. Isnt that why Conte's top target was naingolan.I'd prefer a master at one position than a jack of all trades to be honest. Can is mediocre at best. We have plenty of all rounders in the squad, we need specialists like Cesc and Kante.
No, hes average at best.Is Can really that good to warrant these praises? I'm sorry but I can't see it
when I said that he can be used as a CAM or as a CB, I didnt mean to use him in those positions. I was just implying that he is very good in both attack and defense.This is a nonsensical argument, i'm literally scratching my head at it. Sanchez is a winger, who can back up as striker, so yes i'd sign him as a winger, because he is a world class winger, not as a midfielder/ wingback/ CAM/ striker. Essien was a box to box midfielder, that was his position, and he was the best in the world for several years. So yes, i'd sign him as a box-to box midfielder, not a CAM, CB, and left back. Azpilicueta is a better player in all of his positions than Cahill, so obviously i'd prefer him in my team.
I'm not getting into the 'ive watched more games than you' thing, as i'm not 8 years old. Versatile players are useful, i never debated that, in that rare occasion that someone gets sent off then great, they can swap positions. But there is no point signing a player who is just 'good' all over that park as opposed to someone who is great in one position. A player can only play in one position at one time, i'd rather they actually have a specified role rather than being seen as someone who fills in a vacant spot.
An example, Naby Keita is valued at 70m this summer but his contract will have a clause of 50m next summer.I'm wandering, and maybe someone on here can clarify this for me. But why isn't there a massive raid for RB Leipzig players ? I mean, the Bundesliga is a lot harder than Ligue 1 but Monaco is losing players at an unprecedented speed.
Well, the Monaco players proved themselves in the CL. That's valued a lot more by all the top clubs.I'm wandering, and maybe someone on here can clarify this for me. But why isn't there a massive raid for RB Leipzig players ? I mean, the Bundesliga is a lot harder than Ligue 1 but Monaco is losing players at an unprecedented speed.
Look at their ownership...they're hardly in the need of funds...I'm wandering, and maybe someone on here can clarify this for me. But why isn't there a massive raid for RB Leipzig players ? I mean, the Bundesliga is a lot harder than Ligue 1 but Monaco is losing players at an unprecedented speed.
I think Leipzig will (and should) outright refuse to sell players, it's healthy for the Bundesliga to finally have another team that can compete financially with Bayern.Look at their ownership...they're hardly in the need of funds...
But they are very, very far away from that. The direct duel showed that the gap between these clubs is huge, and I don't see any German team reaching Bayern's level within the next 5 years. As a German I can tell you it's hard to find a more boring league across Europe than the Bundesliga. It's really funny to see German football fans being confused about why the PL is so much more popular internationally and more lucrative, rather than our "best league in the world".I think Leipzig will (and should) outright refuse to sell players, it's healthy for the Bundesliga to finally have another team that can compete financially with Bayern.
True, they won't challenge them in the short term, but I think what they're building there, long term, is a potential threat to Bayern's dominance. They're growing young talents, buying smart and playing good football. I watch a fair bit of the bundesliga myself, and yeah, it gets tedious watching teams slug it out for second knowing first place is wrapped up before christmas every year. I enjoyed watching dortmund but they've been far away from another title challenge for what seems like an age now, and they're being siphoned of their best players constantly, it's so disappointing because other than Chelsea, obviously, they're the team I like the most.But they are very, very far away from that. The direct duel showed that the gap between these clubs is huge, and I don't see any German team reaching Bayern's level within the next 5 years. As a German I can tell you it's hard to find a more boring league across Europe than the Bundesliga. It's really funny to see German football fans being confused about why the PL is so much more popular internationally and more lucrative, rather than our "best league in the world".
The recent development of Dortmund is indeed a bit sad, their rise under Klopp was the best thing that happened to the BL in a long time. You're right about Leipzig, and I cannot understand why whole Germany hates them so much, after all they spend about 50m last year, and not 200m or something. The truth is money doesn't score goals, but clever management can, and what this all new club achieved with those 50m in transfer sums last year was more than impressive! Probably the BL was just a bit shocked how fast their traditional big clubs could be overtaken.True, they won't challenge them in the short term, but I think what they're building there, long term, is a potential threat to Bayern's dominance. They're growing young talents, buying smart and playing good football. I watch a fair bit of the bundesliga myself, and yeah, it gets tedious watching teams slug it out for second knowing first place is wrapped up before christmas every year. I enjoyed watching dortmund but they've been far away from another title challenge for what seems like an age now, and they're being siphoned of their best players constantly, it's so disappointing because other than Chelsea, obviously, they're the team I like the most.
People hate new things, and love the status quo.The recent development of Dortmund is indeed a bit sad, their rise under Klopp was the best thing that happened to the BL in a long time. You're right about Leipzig, and I cannot understand why whole Germany hates them so much, after all they spend about 50m last year, and not 200m or something. The truth is money doesn't score goals, but clever management can, and what this all new club achieved with those 50m in transfer sums last year was more than impressive! Probably the BL was just a bit shocked how fast their traditional big clubs could be overtaken.
So if Leipzig are smart, and last season certainly looked like they are, they could indeed be a threat in the long term