Random Rumours

Linked to Thomas Lemar on a loan with an option to buy.

Wouldn't be against that myself. Low risk, was great at Monaco.

 
Linked to Thomas Lemar on a loan with an option to buy.

Wouldn't be against that myself. Low risk, was great at Monaco.
The old link to Thomas Lemar yet again. This comes up every time. Arsenal to emerge favourites, drama, drama, drama...and nothing happens. That said, I wouldn't be against him either.

 
Nope, I wouldn’t be against Lemar either. Could turn out to be a shrewd signing while his value is low, like Kovacic.

Kovacic is worth far more than 40m now, even though it didn’t seem the case at the time.

 
Linked to Thomas Lemar on a loan with an option to buy.

Wouldn't be against that myself. Low risk, was great at Monaco.
How has he been at Atletico? I haven’t watched them since he signed there.

 
How has he been at Atletico? I haven’t watched them since he signed there.
He has been crap; and i will seriously be against it. It is in no way a Kovacic type situation where he was highly rated as a young player. This is a player who had one decent league in Ligue 1 with Monaco, and was suddenly valued at £80m. He has been awful in the few games he has played for Atletico Madrid.

Considering he plays mainly on the left where we have no need, it’s all paper talk. 

 
dont rate lemar tbh, he is a decent player, but has no outstanding attributes. 

Not particularly quick or dynamic.

Doesnt score or create many goals. 

Willian is twice the player, and even he divides opinion.

 
Whenever I watched Lemar at Monaco he looked average, not surprised he got found out at Madrid.

 
How has he been at Atletico? I haven’t watched them since he signed there.
Has the occasional (1 out of 5 good game and 1 out of 10 worldie attempted pass successfully made) decent-ish game. Overall pretty crap.

Willian is better and I have mixed feelings about Willian

 
I would like it just because he's not a fit at Atletico... they play a 4-4-2 a lot, and he's not a center forward, since the bought Felix, I don't think they play with a position for him. Think he'd fit well on the right side here; of a 4-3-3 or 4-2-3-1 as a back up trying to prove himself, he has a good strike from range and is left footed. If this is a loan to buy. He at least would bring a few things we don't have. Could see a nice situation with James overlapping him, with defenders having to fear the left footed shot from distance. Also seems like a prime candidate to get better as he hasn't played as much on the right side, but it'd be a fairly natural fit as a left footed winger.

 
Nope, I wouldn’t be against Lemar either. Could turn out to be a shrewd signing while his value is low, like Kovacic.

Kovacic is worth far more than 40m now, even though it didn’t seem the case at the time.
45m euros...pretty much the same worth since he signed the contract.

Lemar hasn't scored and didn't set up a goal this season after being on the pitch for over 900 minutes. If he can't make his presence felt in La liga and in the CL, I think he would totally flop if he ever came here.

 
"Lemar hasn't scored and didn't set up a goal this season after being on the pitch for over 900 minutes. If he can't make his presence felt in La liga and in the CL, I think he would totally flop if he ever came here."

Not sure where you're going with this statement. We struggled against the 6th place team in La Liga. Atletico is probably a slightly better team than us right now, and they don't really play in a way that fits him. Not to say he'll be great, but I wouldn't brush him off on how he's done a very good squad.

 
"Lemar hasn't scored and didn't set up a goal this season after being on the pitch for over 900 minutes. If he can't make his presence felt in La liga and in the CL, I think he would totally flop if he ever came here."

Not sure where you're going with this statement. We struggled against the 6th place team in La Liga. Atletico is probably a slightly better team than us right now, and they don't really play in a way that fits him. Not to say he'll be great, but I wouldn't brush him off on how he's done a very good squad.
He has had 1 decent season in his whole career. 

4 league goals in 2 and half years across france and Spain. 

Really poor for a winger.

 
"If he can't make his presence felt in La liga and in the CL, I think he would totally flop if he ever came here."

This is more the line I don't get... it makes it sound like La Liga is sub par... when they've produced 5 of the last 6 Champions League champions as well as 2 of the last 6 Runner ups.

"He has had 1 decent season in his whole career.
4 league goals in 2 and half years across france and Spain.
Really poor for a winger."

That's the thing... I've seen him play for Atleti maybe 3/4 times, and don't really see where he should be scoring - as they seem to me to be the best counter attacking team in Europe. They had a fun win today against Barca, but believe their possession was only 27%. They beat Levante with 39% poss, and Betis with 33%. They've only scored 22 in 19 games, but sit 3rd in the table. I'm just not sure how involved in a pure counter 4-4-2 he's supposed to be in scoring. The last 3 they had under 40%. I see 8 men defending in the box for Atleti a lot, but their attacks seem to be more of 2 or 3 .

 
"If he can't make his presence felt in La liga and in the CL, I think he would totally flop if he ever came here."

This is more the line I don't get... it makes it sound like La Liga is sub par... when they've produced 5 of the last 6 Champions League champions as well as 2 of the last 6 Runner ups.

"He has had 1 decent season in his whole career.
4 league goals in 2 and half years across france and Spain.
Really poor for a winger."

That's the thing... I've seen him play for Atleti maybe 3/4 times, and don't really see where he should be scoring - as they seem to me to be the best counter attacking team in Europe. They had a fun win today against Barca, but believe their possession was only 27%. They beat Levante with 39% poss, and Betis with 33%. They've only scored 22 in 19 games, but sit 3rd in the table. I'm just not sure how involved in a pure counter 4-4-2 he's supposed to be in scoring. The last 3 they had under 40%. I see 8 men defending in the box for Atleti a lot, but their attacks seem to be more of 2 or 3 .

 
I'm just pointing out that he can't make his mark in a less physical league and thus he might be a ghost in the PL. La Liga might have CL winners in Real Madrid in the recent years but that's due to a many factors, one of them being a less demanding league. At least that's how I see it.

I know that in the past we signed players like Pedro that couldn't find his place in Barcelona but that doesn't mean that we should continue signing rejects that didn't make it in their clubs of choice. Pedro might be just as lightweight as Lemar, he had the technique and pace to cover for it and a good work ethic, but Lemar didn't actually show the quality of Pedro in La Liga.

 
I would be happy with Dries Mertens if we could sign him this January.

It's short-term thinking but in the short-term we need to do enough to finish in the top 4. He's versatile, has good goalscoring instincts (which we don't have nearly enough of in our team) and won't cost a lot.

Additionally, he doesn't put Tammy into a direct duel like signing Dembele would. Mertens could play alongside/around him as well as through the middle by himself, and for now, I think that will suit us better.

 
Back
Top