Sydney Chelsea - after reading your post, its motivated me to re-register to the CSR forums (formerly MrPez) , after I was content to just be a browser
I was at the game, and agree with you and disagree with you on several counts. I have to concede in advance, that I haven't as yet had a chance to see a replay of the game, or read any reports.
First I'll start with my agreements.
- (1) The crowd and the game were both fantastic. To get almost 40,000 and breaking the previous record by 13,000 is a fantastic testament to A-League and the Melbourne. Johnny Warren would've been proud.
- (2) Sydney played well, considering you were 10 men for most of the game. Coming back with 2 goals, was a great effort, and Carney's goal
was a cracker. I think our marking was quite poor for the Fyfe goal.
- (3) Bolton is the best keeper in the A-league, without doubt in my opinion. Don't know why he isn't playing overseas.
Now for the disagreements:
- (1) I did happen to see the Adrian Leijer incident. You've done him a vast injustice and frankly your assessment either suggests to me that you were incredibly bitter at the time of writing (very likely by the look of it), or you really need to watch the incident again. You seem to highlight that Leijer ran towards Middleby. Well what would you expect, Middleby had the ball, and Leijer is a defender. Yes body contact was made, and it was unfortunate that Middleby came off injured, but it was a foul, nothing more. Leijer is a fair, and a bright prospect and will be too good for the A-league very soon in my opinion.
As far as I saw, it was the Fred incident that you should be jumping up and down about. Fended your player off with an elbow, when the ball wasn't anywhere close, and i'm surprised he wasn't given a red. Can't excuse him for that
And I also see it as hypocritical to blast a player for upteen paragraphs for an agressive challenge in play, with only a minor mention of the indicent when your captain kicked one of our players who was on the ground at the time. It wasn't during play either. And we played disgracefully?????
(2) I can't comment on the Allesandro penalty without seeing a replay but it looked reasonable to me at the time. Bolton did get yellow carded for his challenge. But I may have to take your word for it on that one.
You do have to admit though, Allessandro showed some amazing ability and absolutely owned your defence.
Congrats to the Cove in their light Blue colours for getting there in such good numbers, but I couldn't hear them from where i was sitting. Did happen to hear one of the Melbourne chants "Your so crap, Yorke left you for Sunderland" - made me chuckle
At the end of the day, we couldn't have asked for a better game. Once again well done Sydney for the great contest, and I'm sure it has done wonders for putting a strong foothold for Football in this AFL dominated city