The 7th Player

[Mod]

Loz is busy away on work but has emailed this to me as he is needing the answer (to win some drink or something)

Anyone have any idea who it is?

Who are the 7 English footballers who have played for 3 clubs that have, at some point in their history, won the Champions League/European Cup.

Here are 6, who is the outstanding one?

David Beckham

Paul Ince

Stan Collymore

David Platt

Dion Dublin

Tony Cascarino (he played for Ireland but is actually English)

[andy]

Loz is busy away on work but has emailed this to me as he is needing the answer (to win some drink or something)

Anyone have any idea who it is?

Who are the 7 English footballers who have played for 3 clubs that have, at some point in their history, won the Champions League/European Cup.

Here are 6, who is the outstanding one?

David Beckham

Paul Ince

Stan Collymore

David Platt

Dion Dublin

Tony Cascarino (he played for Ireland but is actually English)

I am told Gary Charles - Notts Forest, Aston Villa, Benfica

[The Moos]

Nigel Clough?

[andy]

Nigel Clough?

Only Manure and Notts Forest

[bjd]

Only Manure and Notts Forest

Did Clough play for Utd ?

[sexelk]

was thinking wilkins but don't think psg won the european cup

chelsea and gers haven't

[cassiya]

Steve McManaman

[The Moos]

Only Manure and Notts Forest

Not United. He played for Notts Forest, Liverpool and Man City.

[andy]

Not United. He played for Notts Forest, Liverpool and Man City.

Yes you are right.. apologie s.. always get Livepoo and Maunre mixed up ;)

But still not 3 teams that have won the Eruopean Cup/CL

[andy]

Steve McManaman

No ..

I think it is just the 7 as per orginal post

1. Beckham - Man U, Milan, Real

2. Ince - Man U Liverpool, Inter

3. Collymore - Liverpool, Notts Forest, Villa

4. Platt - Juve, Villa, Notss Forest

5. Dublin- Man U, Villa, Celtic

6. Cascarino - Villa, Celtic.. and I think Red Star ??

7. Charles - Forest, Villa, Benfica

Been going round the office all afternoon !

[bjd]

No ..

I think it is just the 7 as per orginal post

1. Beckham - Man U, Milan, Real

2. Ince - Man U Liverpool, Inter

3. Collymore - Liverpool, Notts Forest, Villa

4. Platt - Juve, Villa, Notss Forest

5. Dublin- Man U, Villa, Celtic

6. Cascarino - Villa, Celtic.. and I think Red Star ??

7. Charles - Forest, Villa, Benfica

Been going round the office all afternoon !

Marseille ? But werent they stripped of it ?

[andy]

Marseille ? But werent they stripped of it ?

You got me .. but Bill in the office, who is similar to Stato in apearance and one of these people who can real off nearly all the FA cup goal scorers, reckons that Red Starr Beat Marseille.. and Marseille never won it !

Cascarino played for both

[bjd]

You got me .. but Bill in the office, who is similar to Stato in apearance and one of these people who can real off nearly all the FA cup goal scorers, reckons that Red Starr Beat Marseille.. and Marseille never won it !

Cascarino played for both

He played for Red Star 93 which is a French lower league team, not Red Star Belgrade! Red Star Belgrade did win the European Cup beating Marseille on pens , i think in 91.

Marseille won the European Cup in 93, but were stripped of it a few months later im sure.

Im not convinced he belongs on the list, not least because he played for Ireland!

Edited June 11, 2009 by bjd

[andy]

He played for Red Star 93 which is a French lower league team, not Red Star Belgrade! Red Star Belgrade did win the European Cup beating Marseille on pens , i think in 91.

Marseille won the European Cup in 93, but were stripped of it a few months later im sure.

Im not convinced he belongs on the list, not least because he played for Ireland!

You know more than me ;) .. it must be Marseille then .. I would neve rhave got it if it wasnt listed in the original post.

Just about to give Bill a kick in and pinch his lunch money again !

Edited June 11, 2009 by andy

[loz]

I am told Gary Charles - Notts Forest, Aston Villa, Benfica

Sir I salute you. I had a midnight deadline to get it - I am now owed 5 pints.

I do feel I was cheated as the orringla quesiton I was set was for 6 players and I got 6 because I had Cascarino and that was not in my mates list so he upped it to 7.

[andy]

Sir I salute you. I had a midnight deadline to get it - I am now owed 5 pints.

I do feel I was cheated as the orringla quesiton I was set was for 6 players and I got 6 because I had Cascarino and that was not in my mates list so he upped it to 7.

Well Bill (the sad git at work) tried to win his dinner money back over the weekend and come up with an 8th ! .. I have already punched him but he may have done it.

John Gidman - Liverpool (youth, question does not spesify youth team), Manure, Villa

I tried to get him on the fact that he is scouse so not English, but he wasn't having it.

[andy]

Well Bill (the sad git at work) tried to win his dinner money back over the weekend and come up with an 8th ! .. I have already punched him but he may have done it.

John Gidman - Liverpool (youth, question does not spesify youth team), Manure, Villa

I tried to get him on the fact that he is scouse so not English, but he wasn't having it.

Oh my good god.. this man cannot get any more sad he's come up with a 9th !

Laurie Cunningham Played for Real Madrid, Manure (on Loan) and Marseille

[TheWestwayWonder]

wow, cunningham is a good one, one of those pre-modern footballers who was a globetrotter in his career.

But the other guy....well, I dont know how he came up with that