What do members on here think about about James McCarthy, the lad at Wigan Athletic?

I think this guy is a talent who has done well at Wigan since signing from Hamilton. He is one player that I think that Chelsea should go after in this summer's transfer market.

He would probably need a season to adjust to our style and the Premiership a bit more.

Which is why it wouldnt work. Our fans would be ripping him apart after 3 bad games.

He is Irish not Scottish.

Wouldnt even consider him myself. Not proven in the slightest. Not saying he wont be good in the future, but at the minute he doesnt offer anything that our youngsters dont imo.

Also Conor Clifford in the youths is the future of midfield.

Also Conor Clifford in the youths is the future of midfield.

alongside McEachran.

He is Irish not Scottish.

he is scot born picked Ireland because of grandparents

What do members on here think about about James McCarthy, the lad at Wigan Athletic?

I think this guy is a talent who has done well at Wigan since signing from Hamilton. He is one player that I think that Chelsea should go after in this summer's transfer market.

believe this or not ,this lad was watched by Barca scouts on more than one occasion whilst at Hamilton

he is scot born picked Ireland because of grandparents

I am pretty sure he actually wanted to play for Scotland but chose Ireland after Scotland rejected him at youth football level. (bit of a gaff there!)

He also spent time on trial at Liverpool.

He also spent time on trial at Liverpool.

I take it he was found not guilty?

I take it he was found not guilty?

Really?

Despite the prosecution having actual CCTV footage of him attacking a DJ and then having to be restrained by his mates? I find it hard to believe any judge would fail to convict with that amount of over-whelming evidence in front of him. Wait a minute................... in Liverpool you say?

Really?

Despite the prosecution having actual CCTV footage of him attacking a DJ and then having to be restrained by his mates? I find it hard to believe any judge would fail to convict with that amount of over-whelming evidence in front of him. Wait a minute................... in Liverpool you say?

his 6 other mates were found guilty though so everyone wins....except the poor sod that was beaten up of course.

He's very small and lightweight but great on the ball, imagine he's still got a bit of growing to do but.

Never Chelsea class in his life but.

he is scot born picked Ireland because of grandparents

So yeah, he is Irish.

I have a sneaking suspision that CHD is Irish too.

I agree though, that I don't think we should sign someone like him in ahead of our own youth

I have a sneaking suspision that CHD is Irish too.

I am indeed. Those detective skills you have are top notch.

I am pretty sure he actually wanted to play for Scotland but chose Ireland after Scotland rejected him at youth football level. (bit of a gaff there!)

He also spent time on trial at Liverpool.

your right i think their was a rift but i think his Gps make him eligible

So yeah, he is Irish.

not what the passport says

not what the passport says

Think you will find his Irish passport says he is Irish.

Think you will find his Irish passport says he is Irish.

birthlines may say differant ;)

:D

listen in all honesty Ireland have a good young player there, good luck to both mostly having a laugh with you :D

listen in all honesty Ireland have a good young player there, good luck to both mostly having a laugh with you :D

I know, he and Conor Clifford will lift the World cup for us :)

I know, he and Conor Clifford will lift the World cup for us :D

just 2 players? they must be incredible... :)