I often listen to a classic rock station on my satellite radio and they play 60s and 70s vinyl tracks. Mostly they play the same old tracks over and over with occasional album tracks that are less heard. But the big thing for me is who they don't play and who they do play.

For example in my opinion

Billy Joel is NOT rock but Bob Seger is

Elton John is NOT rock but Jackson Brown is.

They don't play Joni Mitchell but I would put her in a rock category though I might be wrong - they don't play her though.

Who is not rock in your opinion?

They never or rarely play Jefferson Airplane but to me they are clearly rock. They don't play It's a Beautiful Day but anyway were they rock? I never hear Zappa, I am sick of the Stones and Led Zep. Is Richie Havens rock? Do you need a band to be a rock star or can acoustic solo artists be classified.

Interested to hear your views.

(I kid, of course!)

Edited January 29, 201016 yr by blizeH

I would say a Woodstock DVD would make a nice b'day gift for you, Lauren. Or Monterrey.

Velvet Underground - Rock

Nirvana - Not rock

I would say a Woodstock DVD would make a nice b'day gift for you, Lauren. Or Monterrey.

actually I prefer the Band's Last Waltz if you wanna give me that. Birthday is in March!!

Great stuff - Dylan, Van the Man, Neil Young. Joni too if I recall...

Maybe we can get Joni to play your at your party

Edited January 30, 201016 yr by ThunderDan

rock is....usually guitar band played at a certain pace and a guitar solo to massage the leads ego.It can be played by cool folk,but usually twats. On amore serious note i think it was a style of music white kids played and it mutated into this sound, it covers a wide area progresive, hard, etc. very good but difficult question that i have failed to answer

At it's very core, it is anti-establishment

Blueberad - Rock

Yorkleyblue - Not rock (damn hippies)

- rock

Music is whatever you want it to be and thats the beauty.

You cant define 'rock music', you just cant...

Blues ? Punk ? Metal ? Country ? Grunge ?

Its like trying to define a supermarket.

Rock hard until you're tired, then roll.

8 hrs til gametime

Edited January 30, 201016 yr by ThunderDan

Rock hard until you're tired, then roll.

8 hrs til gametime

seven and a half now

Music is whatever you want it to be and thats the beauty.

You cant define 'rock music', you just cant...

Blues ? Punk ? Metal ? Country ? Grunge ?

I agree. When I started uploading music to my iTunes I couldn't believe the amount of music categories there were in there, ridiculous!

I try to keep it simple: - Rock, Rock'n'Roll, Soul, Blues, Reggae, Folk, Country, Pop, MOR, Crap

And Lauren - Jackson Browne, rock - are you sure??? ;)

Graham Parker once said that Billy Joel being a rock star was Russian disinformation to promote his concert in Moscow.

If you like it, it doesn't need a label!

I agree. When I started uploading music to my iTunes I couldn't believe the amount of music categories there were in there, ridiculous!

I try to keep it simple: - Rock, Rock'n'Roll, Soul, Blues, Reggae, Folk, Country, Pop, MOR, Crap

And Lauren - Jackson Browne, rock - are you sure??? ;) ;)

thing is some cross the folk/rock lines - Jackson Browne being one of them - what about Dylan?

Bruce Springsteen - rock music

Morrissey - rock bottom music (sorry Loz! :P )

thing is some cross the folk/rock lines - Jackson Browne being one of them - what about Dylan?

True. I like most of Dylan's stuff up until the mid 70's, and have always thought of his acoustic stuff as folk, and electric stuff folk rock, which of course is over simplified. Joni Mitchell is even harder to define, ranging from folk to folk rock to folk/jazz to crap :P

It's impossible really. One example - do you remember The Sweet from the early 70's? Pure pop followed by glam-rock, but their albums and the b-sides of their singles were almost heavy metal.

True. I like most of Dylan's stuff up until the mid 70's, and have always thought of his acoustic stuff as folk, and electric stuff folk rock, which of course is over simplified. Joni Mitchell is even harder to define, ranging from folk to folk rock to folk/jazz to crap :P

It's impossible really. One example - do you remember The Sweet from the early 70's? Pure pop followed by glam-rock, but their albums and the b-sides of their singles were almost heavy metal.

There's got to be a way to BLOCK BUSTER!

There's got to be a way to BLOCK BUSTER!

Just don't mention LITTLE WILLY, you know how sensitive Geezer can get :P

Small is beautiful!

Small is beautiful!

only men with small ones say size doesn't matter

only men with small ones say size doesn't matter

There is never anything wrong with the size of a mans "seahorse" - it's the tightness, or lack of it, of the womans clam that is the problem.

:P

There is never anything wrong with the size of a mans "seahorse" - it's the tightness, or lack of it, of the womans clam that is the problem.

:P

Oh Moos! I've been pondering over a discreet way to say exactly that - the only metaphors I could come up with were grossly vulgar! Well done you for putting it so tastefully!

Small is fine by me! make of that what you will!

Edited January 30, 201016 yr by moi

You mean that "dangling a worm in a bucket" isn't tasteful?