JMaher94 Posted May 14, 2012 Share Posted May 14, 2012 (edited) Cech 7 - Had a poor start to the season felt he let in quite a few sloppy goals but since RDM's come in seems to have turned the corner and been absolutely excellent. Turnbull 1 - I could have played better than him in that Liverpool game, made one decent save against Blackburn. David Luiz 6 - Same as Cech, had a rocky start to the season and even criticised by certain pundits but has improved since January. Cahill 7 - As fitted in well since he moved here in January but I think he can improve. JT 6 - For as much crtiscism as he takes, he is still a solid defender who does have his off days from time to time but is very consistent usually, although a mark was knocked off for his mistake against Barca. Cole 7 - Same as Luiz, was awful at the beginning of the season but since RDM has arrived, he has been good Ivanovic 8 - He is solid at RB, and has been our best defender all season chipping in with vital goals and can also push forward well. Bosingwa 4 - Useless, only good game was against Barca. Bertrand 6 - Looks like a real prospect, cannot wait to see him in years to come! Looks like a proper replacement for Ash. Ferriera 6 - Rarely lets us down Ramires 8 - In my opinion, our player of the season. Has been at the heart of nearly everything that has come good this season, he once again proves that he is the driving engine of our team almost and his finish against Barca was first class. Lampard 6 - Poor season by his standards but was still our joint top scorer. Mikel 6 - Improved since RDM's arrival, was out of favour under AVB. Meireles 3 - Completely hate him as a first team player, he's a decent squad player to have but do not rate him at all, think he's slow, weak, dosen't put a challenge in and one of the fifty shots from outside the box goes in. Mata 8 - Has been a breath of fresh air and has given us a new dimention, died off slightly towards the end of the season but he's allowed to as he has been used at every opportunity. Essien 4 - Not the same player anymore, can't make those bursting runs and terrific shots. Poor. Romeu 6 - Looked really bright at the start of the year then disappeared off the rictor scale, looked nervous of late. Malouda 3 - Why does he still get in our team? Kalou 6 - Kalou is completely crap in my opinion but believe it or not he seems to fit in quite well and has actually done well when played. Drogba 7 - Poor in the league, infact nearly completely useless but the Drog is a big game player and just keeps providing us with amazing moments. Think he should leave but he will depart a legend in my eyes. Torres 5 - As much as I love Fernando, he has only really shown us what he is capable of in the last two months and he is a great team player but his job is to score goals which he hasn't done enough of. I think he will improve next season and score 20+ Sturridge 6 - Has really frustrated me after a great start to the season but has become a massive hinderence of late with poor performances however he is a joint top scorer with Lamps. Obviously it might have been smarter to do this after Munich but gave it a go now! (Can't judge Hutchinson, Lukaku and Ferriera) What about you guys? Given that 3 is woeful, 4 is poor, 5 is below average, 6 is average, 7 is good, 8 is very good, 9 is excellent Edited May 15, 2012 by JMaher94 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ballack & Blu Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Harsh,very harsh Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JMaher94 Posted May 15, 2012 Author Share Posted May 15, 2012 Harsh,very harsh Who have I been harsh on? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
sals Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Who have I been harsh on? Cahill, JT, Cole, Mikel, Merieles... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Scott Harris Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Meireles has done exactly what i expected him to , i knew he wasn't anything special when we signed him. I think that was harsh giving him a 3 but then give Kalou a 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
matamarryme Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Turnbull a 1? Yeah he isn't great but hey I wouldn't rate his performances a 1. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
EdinburghBlue Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 I love Drogs but he was poor for 90% of the season, just like Torres and both have improved around roughly the same time, but there's a 2 rating jump? Bit harsh, also JT, Cahill, Meireles, and Kalou, a 6? Swap his rating with Turnbull! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Samdwich Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 lol at the meireles hate. "can't put a challenge in" have you been watching Chelsea? did you watch against Barca? Have you seen how many yellows he's got in the CL? He may not be a great tackler but he works f**king hard when asked to protect the defence. Honestly don't get why people hate him, he's come in to be a squad player and has given us a decent squad option, providing energy when needed. Also his goal against Benfica and celebration infront of the Benfica fans :D Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
CunningStunt Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 (edited) Cech - 7.5, Turnbull - 5 David Luiz - 6.5, Cahill - 6.5, Terry - 7.5, Ivanovic - 7.5, Ferreira - 6, Cole - 7, Bertrand - 6.5, Bosingwa - 5.5 Ramires - 8, Mikel - 6.5, Romeu - 6.5, Lampard - 6.5, Mata - 8, Kalou - 6, Malouda - 5, Meireles - 6, Essien - 5.5 Drogba - 7, Torres - 6.5, Sturridge - 7 Edited May 15, 2012 by CunningStunt Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shedpensioner Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 (edited) Cech- 6 Shaky start got much better Bos- 3 If you look 90% of goals conceded lead back to a mistake by Bos! Ash- 6 Once AVB had gone and he stopped sulking played as well as ever! JT- 7 A Couple of silly mistakes (not always football related) otherwise would have scored higher! Luiz- 7 Growing game by game, he's going to be a star! Cahill- 7 As good as I expected, AVB showed how clueless he is by leaving him out! Ryan- 7 Probably our find of the season, a fantastic player, will push Ash close next year! Ivan- 8 Our best defender by a mile, does what he's asked and never moans! Geoff Shreeves is the ultimate c**t for what he did to him in Barcelona! Mikel- 6 Had a few good games and a few bad ones, typical Mikel! Romeu- 6 Started well, got injured and faded! Raul- 6 Not as bad as some think and better than I thought he would be, needs to learn how to tackle! Frank- 6.5 Not up to his usual standards, time is catching up with him! Malouda- 3 Rubbish, out and out rubbish! Rambo- 8 Great athlete, touch is getting better, scored some vital goals! Mata- 8 A joy to watch! Bison- 4.5 Sadly in decline, one of my favourites in recent years so personally I'm gutted! Kalou- 5.5 Not the worst player this year, still makes silly decisions and needs to learn the offside rule! Torres- 6.5 Movement is outstanding, scored THAT goal and overall play was good! Drogba- 7 If he could 'turn up' for every game he would get a 9.5 Danny- 6.5 Needs a big attitude improvement or maybe to get better people around him to advise him properly! I've only included players that have had more than 2/3 games Edited May 15, 2012 by shedpensioner Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HisDogSpot Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Cech 7 - Had a poor start to the season felt he let in quite a few sloppy goals but since RDM's come in seems to have turned the corner and been absolutely excellent. Turnbull 1 - I could have played better than him in that Liverpool game, made one decent save against Blackburn. David Luiz 6 - Same as Cech, had a rocky start to the season and even criticised by certain pundits but has improved since January. Cahill 6 - As fitted in well since he moved here in January but I think he can improve. JT 6 - For as much crtiscism as he takes, he is still a solid defender who does have his off days from time to time but is very consistent usually, although a mark was knocked off for his mistake against Barca. Cole 6 - Same as Luiz, was awful at the beginning of the season but since RDM has arrived, he has been good Ivanovic 8 - He is solid at RB, and has been our best defender all season chipping in with vital goals and can also push forward well. Bosingwa 4 - Useless, only good game was against Barca. Bertrand 6 - Looks like a real prospect, cannot wait to see him in years to come! Looks like a proper replacement for Ash. Ramires 8 - In my opinion, our player of the season. Has been at the heart of nearly everything that has come good this season, he once again proves that he is the driving engine of our team almost and his finish against Barca was first class. Lampard 6 - Poor season by his standards but was still our joint top scorer. Mikel 6 - Improved since RDM's arrival, was out of favour under AVB. Meireles 3 - Completely hate him as a first team player, he's a decent squad player to have but do not rate him at all, think he's slow, weak, dosen't put a challenge in and one of the fifty shots from outside the box goes in. Mata 8 - Has been a breath of fresh air and has given us a new dimention, died off slightly towards the end of the season but he's allowed to as he has been used at every opportunity. Essien 4 - Not the same player anymore, can't make those bursting runs and terrific shots. Poor. Romeu 6 - Looked really bright at the start of the year then disappeared off the rictor scale, looked nervous of late. Malouda 3 - Why does he still get in our team? Kalou 6 - Kalou is completely crap in my opinion but believe it or not he seems to fit in quite well and has actually done well when played. Drogba 7 - Poor in the league, infact nearly completely useless but the Drog is a big game player and just keeps providing us with amazing moments. Think he should leave but he will depart a legend in my eyes. Torres 5 - As much as I love Fernando, he has only really shown us what he is capable of in the last two months and he is a great team player but his job is to score goals which he hasn't done enough of. I think he will improve next season and score 20+ Sturridge 6 - Has really frustrated me after a great start to the season but has become a massive hinderence of late with poor performances however he is a joint top scorer with Lamps. Obviously it might have been smarter to do this after Munich but gave it a go now! (Can't judge Hutchinson, Lukaku and Ferriera) What about you guys? Given that 3 is woeful, 4 is poor, 5 is below average, 6 is average, 7 is good, 8 is very good, 9 is excellent If you cant judge Ferriera then how can Turnbull be judge on what 2 and a half games Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Spiller86 Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 (edited) Cech - 7 . Left exposed too often early in the season but was brilliant in the knockout stages of the CL when it mattered Turnbull 6.5 - Was excellent in the League Cup, particularly with his penalty saves. But Liverpool was just oh dear... so I'm knocking off half a point. Luiz - Maddeningly inconsistent, but his game always required cover, which was rarely available in the suicidal tactics of Villas Boas - 6.5 Cahill - Hard to think of a bad game he has had. Good addition, and should be a lesson to the 'not Chelsea quality' crowd - 7 JT - Not his best season by any stretch, and again was often left exposed by the open system. But he scored plenty of goals and often saved our bacon with his classic last ditch efforts. - 7 Cole - Struggled for much of the season, but has been better recently. Could be something to do with him getting a rest every now and then - 6.5 Ivanovic - Solid at RB. His last ditch efforts are straight out of the JT school, and his play going forward has improved. His finish at Napoli was out of this world. Not the best goal perhaps, but my favourite goal of the season. Still have some questions about his concentration at centre-half in my view - 7.5 Bosingwa - Only ever seems to play well, when he doesn't play right back. Some of his crossing and defending caused me to curse at various stages during the season - 5 Paulo - Wish he got to play more, rarely lets us down when he has - 6.5 Bertrand - Hasn't let himself down during the season, still with things to learn, but a good (home f**king grown!) prospect - 6.5 Ramires - Came into his own this season both in the middle and on the right. His drive from midfield and his goals reminded us all of what Essien used to be. Came up big when it mattered in the FA Cup and against Barca - 9 Lampard - Despite being on the outer with the former manager, he is still equal top scorer. Says alot. His two balls for Ramires against Barca are a big part of us heading back to the big stage again - 7 Mikel - I've been very impressed with him since RDM's takeover. He has looked to take on a bit more with the ball. He was a tower of strength against Barca. Still with some weaknesses, but perhaps 4-2-3-1 is his formation - 6.5 Meireles - I probably judged him harshly because I was very much in the Lampard corner. However, he has played his role, which is all we could have hoped for - 6.5 Mata - A great player one we have been crying out for several seasons. Tired closer to the end of the year, but long may he remain at the Bridge - 8 Essien - Not gotten a lot of a chance, has struggled to regain his former self. His run against Blackburn on the weekend was our first sight of 2006 Essien this season - 5 Romeu - One of AVB's boys and did well in his early hitouts. Looks to have slipped down the pecking order lately. A good start, remains to be seen how often he stays, I think he might well follow AVB to his next gig - 6.5 Malouda - Never seemed to get much of a go, and never really gave much indication that he deserved one when he did play - 5.5 Kalou - Never got a chance under AVB, but has been a big part of our big game plans later in the year. I expect him to start the CL final - 6 Drogba - Not helped by the confusion over who was the key striker. Has come up for us in the big games as usual, but I wish he would come up in a few more games than he does - 6.5 Torres - Miserable for 3/4 of the year. Had a couple of nice moments recently, let's hope he builds on that - 5 Sturridge - He looked our only chance to score at one stage of the year. Has flattered to deceive more recently but he is still young and he'll get better - 7 Nico (how did anyone forget him!) - Scapegoat for our poor form. Sold while Torres made a squillion and delivered less - 6 Alex - Another sacrificial lamb for a sh*t system. No surprise that Carlo has made him a key part of what could still be a title winning defence at PSG. Matter of fact it looks like all of our ridiculous departures are ending up there - 6.5 These could all still change of course after the Bayern match, but I think they are a reasonably good reflection of the season we have had. Edited May 15, 2012 by Spiller86 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JMaher94 Posted May 15, 2012 Author Share Posted May 15, 2012 (edited) Cahill, JT, Cole, Mikel, Merieles... Cole and Cahill maybe deserve a 7 so a little harsh there, Mikel has only played a few good games this year and Meireles was poor pre-Barca (first leg) but I knocked out a point off JT for that poor decision in Barca. Edited May 15, 2012 by JMaher94 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
blizeH Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Interesting how a lot of players, particular Luiz, Mikel and even Cech have improved massively since Robbie came in. Other players, like Sturridge, seem to have done the exact opposite, though you could argue the decline started under AVB also. Ramires is for me, without a doubt, our player of the season. The only players to come close are Mata (oozes quality, but doesn't always put his stamp on the game) and Lampard (fantastic goal record, some superb assists, and has really stepped up in massively important games). Cech has been superb lately also. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
BelgradeCFC Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Cech- 6 Shaky start got much better Bos- 3 If you look 90% of goals conceded lead back to a mistake by Bos! Ash- 6 Once AVB had gone and he stopped sulking played as well as ever! JT- 7 A Couple of silly mistakes (not always football related) otherwise would have scored higher! Luiz- 7 Growing game by game, he's going to be a star! Cahill- 7 As good as I expected, AVB showed how clueless he is by leaving him out! Ryan- 7 Probably our find of the season, a fantastic player, will push Ash close next year! Mikel- 6 Had a few good games and a few bad ones, typical Mikel! Romeu- 6 Started well, got injured and faded! Raul- 6 Not as bad as some think and better than I thought he would be, needs to learn how to tackle! Frank- 6.5 Not up to his usual standards, time is catching up with him! Malouda- 3 Rubbish, out and out rubbish! Rambo- 8 Great athlete, touch is getting better, scored some vital goals! Mata- 8 A joy to watch! Bison- 4.5 Sadly in decline, one of my favourites in recent years so personally I'm gutted! Kalou- 5.5 Not the worst player this year, still makes silly decisions and needs to learn the offside rule! Torres- 6.5 Movement is outstanding, scored THAT goal and overall play was good! Drogba- 7 If he could 'turn up' for every game he would get a 9.5 Danny- 6.5 Needs a big attitude improvement or maybe to get better people around him to advise him properly! I've only included players that have had more than 2/3 games I think you forgot Ivanovic Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
shedpensioner Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 I think you forgot Ivanovic Oh yeah!! And how could I???? Ivan- 8 Our best defender by a mile, does what he's asked and never moans! Geoff Shreeves is the ultimate c**t for what he did to him in Barcelona! Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MJB Posted May 15, 2012 Share Posted May 15, 2012 Trouble with merieles is that we were going after modric at the time and was seen as a the next best option, when in reality he's nowhere near luca. But he is as people say a good squad player. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts