Jump to content

Kaka Or Robinho?

MannyJello

By MannyJello
in Chelsea FC Rumours

 Share

Kaka or Robinho?  

91 members have voted

  1. 1. If you had to choose only one...

    • Kaka
      65
    • Robinho
      26

Recommended Posts



loz

loz

Posted
Posted

No contest for me. Kaka will deliver week in week out and we would remember him forever more. Robinho will blow hot and cold and disappear frequently. I'm still not convinced I want Robinho at all let alone comparing him with one of the finest players on the planet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites






barak81

barak81

Posted
Posted

its not as simple as wich one, if both where 20 mill then you would take kaka but if robinio is 20 mill and kaka is 70 mill thant id rather take robinio... as we have seen kaka wont garanetee glory though he would be a difference maker. but handing 70 mill over to a broken milan would alow them to really rebuild and re-eshtablish them selves in europe and we have to start looking at these teams as competition rivals like we do domesticaly.

however if it is purely based on which out of the two no price considerd i think a better comparision would be messi or kaka, two players a lot closer in ability

Link to comment
Share on other sites


mad_mac

mad_mac

Posted
Posted
its not as simple as wich one, if both where 20 mill then you would take kaka but if robinio is 20 mill and kaka is 70 mill thant id rather take robinio... as we have seen kaka wont garanetee glory though he would be a difference maker. but handing 70 mill over to a broken milan would alow them to really rebuild and re-eshtablish them selves in europe and we have to start looking at these teams as competition rivals like we do domesticaly.

however if it is purely based on which out of the two no price considerd i think a better comparision would be messi or kaka, two players a lot closer in ability

Good shout, I was assuming the question was just about who would you rather have in the team, irrespective of money involved

Link to comment
Share on other sites




TomP

TomP

Posted
Posted
but handing 70 mill over to a broken milan would alow them to really rebuild and re-eshtablish them selves in europe and we have to start looking at these teams as competition rivals like we do domesticaly.

I don't think we do need to look at Milan, Real or other European powers as rivals really.

They only become our rivals IF we draw them in the Champion's League - and the chances of drawing any one particular big European club are pretty slim. Chances are we are only ever going to play against Milan every 5 years or so in the Champions League. Certainly not often enough to actively NOT sign players from them.

Compeletly the opposite with our Premier League rivals - we are guaranteed to play each of them at least twice, and their results against other clubs in the Premier League effect us as well. So if they strengthen, they are (1) more likely to beat us when we play them (2) more likely to beat other lower clubs, making it harder for us. So not a good idea to pay inflated prices for their players.

In short, giving Milan 70 million for Kaka and letting them rebuild doesn't really effect us. Well at least not in the same way that giving Man United 70 mil for Ronaldo or giving Liverpool 70 million for Torres would.

Within the next season or so, Milan are going to rebuild their sqaud anyway, with or without us buying Kaka. I think for them, the easiest way of getting their hands on the cash needed is to let him go. And if we don't go in for him, they will move on to their next biggest paying option - Real Madrid, who will jump at the chance given that they have been snubbed over Ronaldo.

Basically, if he's on offer, I don't think we should hestitate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BackInBlue

BackInBlue

Posted
Posted

I voted for Kaka but I feel people are underestimating the talents of Robinho. Like someone before me said, if you give me Robinho for 20 mill I would take him before Kaka at 70 mill no doubt. Robinho is one of the top talents around and last season he was finally showing signs of becoming a world class player that his potential suggested early in his career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Elliott

Elliott

Posted
Posted

I voted Robinho purely on what I think we need as a team.

I think we need a winger/striker as we look short in that area, and bringing in Kaka, would only false out someone like Essien, Lamps, Deco or Ballack.

Not only that, but I think £70m for Kaka, as good as he may be, is a stupid amount of money.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...
Please Sign In or Sign Up

Well, this is awkward!

Happy Sunny Days GIF by Atlassian

The Shed End Forum relies on revenue to pay for hosting and upgrades. While we try to keep adverts as unobtrusive as possible, we need to show these to make sure we can stay online and continue to keep the forum running. Over the years costs have become very high.

Could you please allow adverts on this domain by switching it off and whitelisting the website? Some of the advert banners can actually be closed to avoid interference with your experience on The Shed End.

If you don't want to view any adverts while logged in and using your account, consider using the Ad-Free Subscription which is renewable every year. To buy a subscription, log in to your account and click the link under the Newbies forum on the home page.

Cheers now!

Sure, let me in!