13 hours ago, OTL said:

his hair isnt a nice colour

his cheekbones are too high

the tattoo on his neck isnt nice

he was disruptive at man utd and disrespected the genius that is Amorim

his brother posts bad stuff on social media

just an off the wall bit of irrelevance .. he contributed to the goal mid week v benfica and put a few crosses into the penalty area, and he might actually be a useful squad player.

f**k me, if that is the standard, then we’re finished aren’t we?

Mr no final ball, head down run and take hollywood shots to nowhere’s personality isn’t irrelevant, if it was, he’d be a different player. Personalities make or break clubs.

I like Garnacho.

He's better than Gittens and has more end product than Neto.

18 minutes ago, GarnachoCheese said:

He's better than Gittens and has more end product than Neto.

We will have to wait and see on that Pedro has scored some great goals for us and also shown a great work rate when fit.

2 hours ago, strider6004 said:

We will have to wait and see on that Pedro has scored some great goals for us and also shown a great work rate when fit.

Neto has never scored more goals in a single season than 2024/25 or 2023/24 Garnacho. a 19 year old has consistently outscored a player that should be in their prime.

If we wanted work rate we should have saved £60M and offered Mo Farah a contract.

5 hours ago, GarnachoCheese said:

He's better than Gittens and has more end product than Neto.

That's f**king depressing.

52 minutes ago, Scott Harris said:

That's f**king depressing.

Tell me about it ... I can't believe I'm excitedly waiting for Mudryk to come back LOL

7 hours ago, GarnachoCheese said:

He's better than Gittens and has more end product than Neto.

Hmm, not really. At least not to the level in which a post like that can be typed anyway.

Garnacho last season: 36 games, 6 goals (from 83 shots), 2 assists

Pedro Neto last season: 35 games, 4 goals (from 58 shots), 6 assists

2 hours ago, Scott Harris said:

That's f**king depressing.

There were some glimpses from the club World Cup that Gitten might be capable, so far he’s been the biggest flop, but again, if the argument for Garnacho is that he’s better than Gittens, then we’ve entered a dark dark time for that position.

Pedro Neto is the ‘floor’ of what we should see as an ‘acceptable’ PL player. Let’s not overhype him, he’s very very limited.

If he’s the floor, then Garnacho is the dirt underneath it.

Not even a fan of Neto, all the wingers are garbage, aside from Estevao.

1 hour ago, Term_X said:

Hmm, not really. At least not to the level in which a post like that can be typed anyway.

Garnacho last season: 36 games, 6 goals (from 83 shots), 2 assists

Pedro Neto last season: 35 games, 4 goals (from 58 shots), 6 assists

Hmm, yes really.

Garnacho: 3,568 minutes 11 goals 10 assists

Neto: 3,384 minutes 9 goals 9 assists

Garnacho wasn’t able to stat pad in the conference league or CWC either.

Edited October 3, 2025Oct 3 by GarnachoCheese

26 minutes ago, GarnachoCheese said:

Hmm, yes really.

Garnacho: 3,568 minutes 11 goals 10 assists

Neto: 3,384 minutes 9 goals 9 assists

Garnacho wasn’t able to stat pad in the conference league or CWC either.

Is this a parody?

You realise the extra’s you’ve added are the likes of 2 goals against League One Barnsley….. BARNSLEY. Good god man.

1 hour ago, Term_X said:

Is this a parody?

You realise the extra’s you’ve added are the likes of 2 goals against League One Barnsley….. BARNSLEY. Good god man.

Meanwhile Neto was dropping zero goals or assists against Morcambe or Servette… I’ve compared all goals and assists from all comps. Let’s not forget Neto was playing for a top 4 team while Garnacho’s Utd was battling relegation.

9 hours ago, GarnachoCheese said:

Neto has never scored more goals in a single season than 2024/25 or 2023/24 Garnacho. a 19 year old has consistently outscored a player that should be in their prime.

If we wanted work rate we should have saved £60M and offered Mo Farah a contract.

The way I see it is Neto can play either wing and I have only see Garnacho on the left side.

Garnacho may have more speed over a 40-60m sprint and Neto more speed on the ball in the 10-20m range, what I notice is Pedro can either cross or shoot.

I have not see enough on Garnacho to make such a judgement now.

We really need to give him a run of game and hope he delivers. All our other options on the left are poor to terrible, Neto include.

On right I like Neto a lot. On the left he just is not dangerous.

9 hours ago, strider6004 said:

The way I see it is Neto can play either wing and I have only see Garnacho on the left side.

Garnacho may have more speed over a 40-60m sprint and Neto more speed on the ball in the 10-20m range, what I notice is Pedro can either cross or shoot.

I have not see enough on Garnacho to make such a judgement now.

Did your noticing go in depth enough to watch Neto drag the majority of his shots out for a throw in?

49 minutes ago, GarnachoCheese said:

Did your noticing go in depth enough to watch Neto drag the majority of his shots out for a throw in?

No, I tend to notice him working hard to get space to get a corner over yet here is another fact most strikers are doing well if they score with more than one chance in 5 currently.

Harland is on 34%, Kylian Mbappe 26% yet Lautaro Martinez on just 21%.

https://onefootball.com/en/news/ranking-the-top-10-goalscorers-in-europe-by-their-conversion-rate-37618977

Neto often makes a decent contribution

Garnacho looks like he might make a decent contribution

Gittens has not made any or much contribution

...and all that without a grain of data in sight 😉

1 hour ago, OTL said:

Neto often makes a decent contribution

Garnacho looks like he might make a decent contribution

Gittens has not made any or much contribution

...and all that without a grain of data in sight 😉

£160M spent 🤣

1 hour ago, GarnachoCheese said:

£160M spent 🤣

Oh gawd so approx 1.5 squad players with a combined value of say 75 million

Not looking great how on earth to Stewart and winstanley get away with it?

1 hour ago, OTL said:

Not looking great how on earth to Stewart and winstanley get away with it?

Because we grinded out top 4 and won the CWC.

On 02/10/2025 at 05:08, nonotnowjim said:

ridiculous isn't it?

The lad was desperate to come here - and yet he seems to be hated by so many, without hardly having kicked a ball.

That's the problem Jim. He hardly ever kicks the ball.

. He doesn't look like a winner either with that face .

.

Edited October 4, 2025Oct 4 by Sexyfootball

Maresca, dear me, 2 wingers in the team who will both put crosses in and NO striker, Garnacho needs a striker in the team, otherwise he is going to be just like Sancho, beat his man and then have to go backwards because no one will be in the six yard box