Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

The Shed End - Chelsea FC Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Cech or Courtois?

Number 1 Next Season 335 members have voted

  1. 1. Cech or Courtois?

    • Cech
      30%
      101
    • Courtois
      69%
      234

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

The legend worshipers will be de livid but Cech needs serious competition or more probably moving on.The reflexes are not the same anymore,we have seen the bwst of him.I dont want to see him go the same way as SFL ,just another old boy getting a favour from the manager.

 

Cech's relexes have saved our ass on more than one occasion this season.

 

It's like people forget the other games where he performs brilliantly. Jaaskelainen made a mistake for West Ham yesterday, do you think they are asking for him to be replaced ? Keepers, like outfield players, are allowed to make mistakes. Cech rarely makes mistakes like this and has been one of our most inform players in the last 3 or 4 seasons. This is Cech's 10th season at the club, you couldn't find another goalkeeper who has made less howlers than him in that time.

 

If Courtois ever does get a chance i fear for him if he makes a mistake.

Cech's relexes have saved our ass on more than one occasion this season.

 

It's like people forget the other games where he performs brilliantly. Jaaskelainen made a mistake for West Ham yesterday, do you think they are asking for him to be replaced ?

 

If they had Courtous on loan im sure they would be talking about it

The truth is thuth is that Cech never has reached the levels he had before the injury,thats why I hate Hunt.You have know when to let go,sorry but Cech is on his way down.

I'm not sure why it's being assumed that some people want Courtois over Cech based on just yesterday?

Petr Cech is a fantastic goalkeeper and a fantastic servant to Chelsea. Unfortunately elements of his game haven't quite been the same since his injury, but there is no questioning his ability.

The reality is we have a young goalkeeper who has the potential to be the best in the world (he's probably in the top 5 already) and you can't afford to let talent like that slip through. Look what happened to Cudicini when Cech came, I'm sure people felt the same way then, but looking back what a decision that was!

We can't have both because Courtois certainly doesn't want to play second fiddle. Courtois for me.

How do we know that Petr wouldn't accept being 2nd to Courtois ? After all he has had 10 great years, he seems to be happy in London, he's on a good salary, he would still get quite a few games (cups etc)..
Not a bad lot ????
If i had to choose between the two for next season it would have to be Courtios, we just can't afford to lose him, and he is at the beginning of his career, unlike Petr unfortunately.

The truth is thuth is that Cech never has reached the levels he had before the injury,thats why I hate Hunt.You have know when to let go,sorry but Cech is on his way down.

 

What do you base that on?

 

If Courtois ever does get a chance i fear for him if he makes a mistake.

 

Can't wait for that. Especially if Cech ends up at another top club and Courtois goes the way of Joe Hart.

The reality is we have a young goalkeeper who has the potential to be the best in the world (he's probably in the top 5 already) and you can't afford to let talent like that slip through. Look what happened to Cudicini when Cech came, I'm sure people felt the same way then, but looking back what a decision that was!

 

Cudicini was never best in the world though.

 

 

How do we know that Petr wouldn't accept being 2nd to Courtois ? After all he has had 10 great years, he seems to be happy in London, he's on a good salary, he would still get quite a few games (cups etc)..

Not a bad lot ????

If i had to choose between the two for next season it would have to be Courtios, we just can't afford to lose him, and he is at the beginning of his career, unlike Petr unfortunately.

 

No professional player would or should ever be happy playing second fiddle. Cech is not someone who will sit on the bench when he knows he is good enough to start for any top club in europe. PS. we can afford to lose him, because we have Cech.

Edited by Stim

So what if Cech is going to another top club,we have seen the best of him ,end of.Look to the future I have spoken to many fans from other PL teams and they dont see Cech as a 'top top' keeper anymore.

they obviously weren't watching us win the champions league, when he was just as huge as drogba...cech is still quality, every keeper makes errors...

 

however, I don't want us to lose courtois...it pains me to say it, but I would like to see courtois as no.1 sooner rather than later...Chelsea has to come first and he is just too good and too young to be allowed to strengthen a European rival

Cech is the best keeper in the world.

 

Courtois will be waiting another 3 years i think, before getting the number one shirt.

He won't wait that long, he'll be off to barca...his contract expires 2016 and he refused to sign a new on in the summer cos he wants to see what Chelsea's plans are first...if he's bombed out on loan again, I think chelsea will find it hard to keep him

I say we bring Courtois back next season and make him and Cech battle it out for the no 1 shirt, i know they both probably won't like it but i think it would be a perfect way to judge just how good Courtois is. I don't want to just throw Courtois into the first team as soon as he returns. He has never played in a league as physical as the Premier League before and no matter how good he is it's going to take time to adapt.

We need Courtois back next year to battle with Cech. Lets face it, there's no way Mark would start unlesss Cech is injured or have a string of Joe Hart type of games. Mark is good, but not here to challenge Cech. If Courtois believes his ability, he should come back and fight his spot next year

So what if Cech is going to another top club,we have seen the best of him ,end of.Look to the future I have spoken to many fans from other PL teams and they dont see Cech as a 'top top' keeper anymore.

 

They also don't think Terry is a good CB, and Lampard only scores deflections and tap ins. Shall I go on ?

 

 

I say we bring Courtois back next season and make him and Cech battle it out for the no 1 shirt, i know they both probably won't like it but i think it would be a perfect way to judge just how good Courtois is. I don't want to just throw Courtois into the first team as soon as he returns. He has never played in a league as physical as the Premier League before and no matter how good he is it's going to take time to adapt.

 

 

It would be detrimental to both keepers and the team. Goalkeeper isn't a position you rotate.

Again Terry is a good CB now,but is he really the same player as 5 years ago?Look at the goals we conceded and you will find he has fair share of blame.SFL shouldnt be even on the bench,if he isnt even half of player he was.He is only playing because JM still thinks is 2004.

So what if Cech is going to another top club,we have seen the best of him ,end of.Look to the future I have spoken to many fans from other PL teams and they dont see Cech as a 'top top' keeper anymore.

 

The same muppets who never rated Terry, Lampard or Drogba either. Who cares what they think? Cech is massively underappreciated, including by some of our own fans, who seemingly can't wait to ditch the best keeper we've ever had (and still among the best in the world) because they think the grass is greener somewhere else.

Whilst I love big Petr......he was poor at the weekend, that second goal was as soft a goal as you'll ever see. There's been quite a few goals this season where I've thought, come on Pete you could have had that.

Some days he is razor sharp and looks fantastic, but his mistakes seem to be more common these days

If his blunders continue at a rapid pace I wouldn't be against the idea of bringing Courtois back next season and let them battle it out.

We'd have to be fairly confident that Courtois would do better before making the move....this season will be rather telling.

Edited by Zola

Cech is the best keeper in the world.

 

Courtois will be waiting another 3 years i think, before getting the number one shirt.

 

Courtois has no reason to put his career on hold, and I agree Cech has been the best in the world, but lets face it the only way you can go from the top is down, and look I've said this many times, Cech is an absolute god and one of the most legendary players for Chelsea in our history, but how can one say that we should keep Cech for another 2 years and let Courtois go based on what Cech has done for us in the past.

 

Many great players have remained gods at football clubs because they knew when to step down, take Drogba for instance. He left at the absolute peak a professional footballer could be at club level, with the champions league trophy, if he had stayed for another season and scored only like 6-7 goals what would our impression of him be then, still legend, but not as much, yes? You must admit it.

 

It's a question that will always raise controversy and will infinitely have 2 sides to it. But common sense sees that we may have to make a bit of a sacrifice in order to gain another keeper that for the next 15 years has every possibility to become the best in the world by a long shot.

 

Courtois all the way for me, that doesn't mean I don't honour Cech, Cech is a god.

So in 8 years time when the next big thing comes along do we just ditch Courtois as well and so on and so on? Just because you have the next big thing doesnt mean he is ready to take the top spot.

Courtois has proved nothing in the Premier league. He could come here and flop around like De Gea did in his first season. He may not adjust at all. So we get rid of the best keeper in the league and one of the top 5 in the world and just hope the new kid can cope?

It's a tough decision for the club to make.

 

The biggest problem is Cech is too young to be talking about replacing him. Just to put it in perspective, he's several years younger now than Van Der Sar was when he signed for United. He still has a long time left in the game.

 

My gut feeling is, if push comes to shove next summer and they have to pick one or the other (and assuming Cech's form doesn't drop alarmingly) I think the club will stick with Cech. Main reason being he's a proven goalkeeper.

It's a tough decision for the club to make.

 

The biggest problem is Cech is too young to be talking about replacing him. Just to put it in perspective, he's several years younger now than Van Der Sar was when he signed for United. He still has a long time left in the game.

 

VDS didnt have a life threatening injury that puts him at risk everytime he plays

 

So in 8 years time when the next big thing comes along do we just ditch Courtois as well and so on and so on? Just because you have the next big thing doesnt mean he is ready to take the top spot.

Courtois has proved nothing in the Premier league. He could come here and flop around like De Gea did in his first season. He may not adjust at all. So we get rid of the best keeper in the league and one of the top 5 in the world and just hope the new kid can cope?

 

De Gea was never the best keeper in spain like Courtois, and inspite of his 'flopping around' in his first year, hes now one of the best keepers in the league

Edited by Lane

I dont think he is that great at all. Its only because he plays at United that it makes him look better than he is.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.
Background Picker
Customize Layout

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.